Newsflash: I considered running for the CalPERS Board seat elected by retirees. See video recorded on March 8, 2022. However, I decided to continue in my role as an individual investor advocate, with a slightly increased focus on my retirement system, CalPERS. I hope to work to assist current and future Board members on issues such as those discussed below.
Our healthcare benefits and services should be second to none. We should use our investments to create a better world while earning returns that ensure our monthly checks and continued public support. We should govern CalPERS transparently, and our voices should ring in Directors’ ears every minute. Here are a few ideas I’d like to work on:
- Either get CalPERS out of private equity investments or bring them in-house. This is an area rife for corruption and bad accounting since terms are secret and there is no mark to market. We have no way of knowing what our investments are really worth. CalPERS should not continue to back legislation that increases the secrecy surrounding such investments. If we do invest in private equities, let’s invest with those that offer double bottom-line returns, such as those that empower workers through increased employee ownership.
- Using data from the Survey of Consumer Finances, researchers found that if businesses were 30% employee-owned, it would produce a significant change in the concentration of wealth. Wealth going to those with below-median wealth would increase from 1% to 6% of total wealth. The net wealth of the average black family would increase by more than 400%, from $24,100 to $106,271. The report breaks out other impacts as well. We are unlikely to see anything like 30% employee ownership in our lifetimes, but we could target 5-10%. I’ve asked the researchers to calculate the difference a 5-10% ownership level by employees would make in wealth distribution.
- I would more carefully scrutinize real estate investment. This is another area subject to corrupting influences.
- My inclination would be to invest the vast majority in index funds, experimenting with smart beta around the edges. More than 75% of the variability in returns is caused by systematic risk, not stock picking. We should overweight based on DEI (diversity, equity, inclusion), employee productivity related to ownership, participation in decision-making, carbon footprint, and other ESG measures correlated with reduced risk and increased earnings.
- CalPERS returns are heavily correlated with GDP. The IMF finds GDP growth is 0.08% lower in the five years following a 1% increase concentration of wealth. In contrast, increasing the share of income to the bottom 20% by 1% is associated with a 0.38% rise in GDP. CalPERS needs to move pay and stock (with votes) from “named executives” to workers to grow the economy and its portfolio and to increase the voice of workers.
- Wealth inequality is directly correlated with political polarization. Our government’s ability to act depends on addressing this paramount social issue.
- CalPERS and other investors have voted on corporate equity plans since 2003. Before voting, CalPERS evaluates the dilutive impact of the plans on our own shares but does not fully consider who will benefit (mostly “named executives” and board members). Companies do not routinely report where those shares go below the level of named executives and board members in a meaningful way. CalPERS should request such reports.
- CalPERS should survey its members on their values and use that information in helping to set both investing and proxy voting policies. Such surveys can be a two-way street to educate members on the issues and educate board/staff on values shared by members. A company like iconik could help facilitate such an effort.
- CalPERS should consider partnering with consumer action groups like SumOfUs, Change.org, and Civex to coordinate campaigns at portfolio companies around issues such as getting CO2, plastics, antibiotics, and other poisons out of our food, air, and soil
- An inspector general should be appointed with authority to audit CalPERS and report to the legislature. We cannot afford another scandal.
- Closed-door meetings and secrecy should be rare and only for legally permissible purposes.
- California election laws should be strictly followed. The plenary authority granted to CalPERS by the Constitution does not exempt them from the law.
- Adopt instant runoff voting or ranked-choice voting to avoid the expense of up to $1 million for runoff elections AND to reduce acrimonious hit pieces by candidates and independent expenditure committees.
I wrote a master’s thesis on worker-elected managerial assignments in California’s civil service, interned with AFSCME, advised Rath Pack when the UFCW converted it to employee ownership, went through SEIU’s capital stewardship program, testified before Adam Schiff about corruption at CalPERS, defended shareholder proposals in federal appeals court (without legal counsel), am currently suing the SEC to overturn Trump-era rules, and host a free weekly discussion forum on corporate accountability with leading theorists and practitioners over Zoom. Unfortunately, I don’t have the temperament or patience to attend countless hours of meetings with the Board and constituents. Instead, I’ve decided I am more suited to advise Board, staff and constituents and hope to be able to do so more effectively in the future.
I started State services under Governor Reagan and spent my first ten years working on healthcare, primarily Medi-Cal. We had cost-plus contracts with Blue Cross and Blue Shield. Whenever we cut costs, California saved money. I saved millions in administrative costs with management audits of each step in the process. Later, I used computer programs and statistical analysis to find fraudulent service providers. I also wrote a study for the State Controller, who sat on the CalPERS Board, that led to PERSCare and PERSChoice.
I earned a master’s in public administration at Cal State, Sacramento, an award for my thesis on worker’s self-management, and a fellowship with the National Institute of Mental Health to research workplace structures that fostered mental health and productivity. I earned an MS in social economy from Boston College, volunteered with AFSCME in Boston, then with the UFCW when workers bought out Rath Pack in Iowa.
After returning to California, I ran the Cooperative Development Program (CDP), where I gained experience lobbying the legislature and building grassroots support to save the program. I also wrote and passed legislation with bipartisan support to address autoimmune illnesses caused by exposure to toxic chemicals. Unfortunately, the governor eliminated CDP’s budget and vetoed the bill that would have addressed autoimmune illnesses.
I then headed legislation, regulations, and other functions (such as Ethics Officer) at the Department of Toxics Substances Control, working 100’s of bills and coordinating with stakeholders from communities to the governor. Although I spent much of my career at the Career Executive Assignment (CEA) level, I found we could never regulate toxic substances in products, only wastes. So, I retired early, deciding to influence companies as a shareholder instead.
As a shareholder advocate, I filed hundreds of proposals to companies voted at annual shareholder meetings. I’m a member of the Interfaith Center for Corporate Responsibility, which has been doing this work for 50 years. Most famously, they helped end apartheid in South Africa. I also work with As You Sow, the Center for Political Accountability, The Shareholder Commons, and others.
As I write this, we just reached an agreement with Pepsi to substantially reduce single-use disposable packages for their products. An earlier deal by As You Sow was with a cereal company. By 2025 the company will stop using grains for their cereal sprayed with glyphosate (a carcinogen) before harvest. Most people know glyphosate kills weeds, but it is also used as a desiccant to dry out grain used to make bread and cereals. So, many people who think they have a problem with gluten are having trouble with glyphosate.
CalPERS is one of the largest shareholders in the world. I have twenty-five years of experience on shareholder issues, including testifying before and getting rules passed by the SEC, representing myself in federal court, including federal appeals court, and suing the SEC to overturn Trump-era rules.
I have worked with CalPERS boards over the years cooperatively whenever possible. For example, I initiated candidate forums. CalPERS refused the use of their auditorium, so I rented a hall the first year and used the CalSTRS auditorium the second. CalPERS finally agreed. We now have candidate forums facilitated by the League of Women Voters. I also won rule changes requiring board members to be elected by a majority vote.
However, I have also taken more aggressive action. I overturned two regulations CalPERS adopted illegally (one on gifts, another on elections). When Congressman Schiff was a State Senator, I testified before his committee on corruption at CalPERS and the need for certain confidential documents to be released to the public after time sensitivities lapsed so officials could be accountable. Senator Schiff’s hearings accelerated investigations and eventual prosecution of CalPERS officials.
When I started working for the State, I joined CSEA and was the first delegate to bring a computer and printer to General Council, writing emergency resolutions from the floor. In addition, I was a steward, newsletter/website editor, headed CSEA’s bylaws committee, and currently serve on CSR’s Investment Committee. I have been a member of RPEA for decades. I also served on boards at Universal Cooperatives, Sacramento Natural Foods Cooperative, Church Co-op Credit Union (instituted lower loans rates for fuel-efficient autos), and am currently a Board Advisor for SoCal Adaptive Sports.
One of my many fun activities is holding free Zoom discussions with thought leaders on corporate accountability. After the forums, we load recordings to YouTube and podcasts. For example, see our recent conversation with Brandon Rees, the head of investing at AFL-CIO, Meredith Miller (co-founder of the Human Capital Management Coalition), Leo Strine, former Chief Justice of Delaware Supreme Court, and Jackie Cook of Morningstar. See CorpEngage.net. I also practice tai chi and will soon be training and playing with a puppy.
This is a placeholder for some archived material on CalPERS. I am finally taking down my PERSwatch site and will maintain what remains of value on this site as time allows. For several years, using the internet site PERSWatch.net, James McRitchie worked together with other CalPERS members to make CalPERS responsive to its members. We worked to enact Article 16 of the Constitution, making CalPERS independent from politicians. We insisted the Board release minutes from closed-door investment sessions. How else could we hold them accountable for their votes? We exposed wasteful spending on $750 coat racks for CalPERS cubicles and the common practice of many Board members of accepting gifts of fine dining and entertainment from contractors.
We pointed out that CalPERS kept reducing the State’s contribution (8 times in 11 years) but did little to increase our benefits; in fact they were eroding. McRitchie ran for the Board several times and ran ads in Capitol Weekly reminding the Board that, according to the Constitution, their primary duty is to members, not employers. Toward the end of 1998, we finally got the Board’s attention and they addressed “equity” issues with SB 400, which raised our retirement substantially through an imperfect vehicle with plenty of flaws.
In addition, we worked to reform the election process. Beginning in 2002, CalPERS began holding a runoff vote if no candidate wins a majority. There will be no more directors elected by 5.5% of the vote. That rule was enacted because board members first voted to prohibit ballot statements that include “candidates’ opinion or positions on issues of general concern to the system’s membership.” We fought that move by contacting members, unions, and the Sacramento Bee, which ran an editorial CalPERS muzzles critics: Ballot rules protect board, keep others in the dark. Then we won real reforms. We are still working to avoid the $1 million cost of runoffs by getting CalPERS to use an instant runoff (IRV) system for elections.
McRitchie’s work in government, business, non-profits, cooperatives, and universities led him to understand that accountability isn’t something easily imposed from the outside; it must be built into the governance structures of our organizations themselves. Not only has he worked to transform the governance structures of CalPERS, but he’s also done the same with corporations. (see corpgov.net)
CalPERS has tremendous transformative potential in creating a sustainable economy by seeking triple bottom-line returns – excellent financial returns, as well as social and environmental benefits. Research demonstrates that companies with good environmental practices, diverse boards, worker ownership, employee participation in decision-making, and democratic corporate governance earn substantially better returns. CalPERS should be encouraging all of the corporations it invests in to have these characteristics and they should use an enhanced indexing strategy to invest more heavily in such companies while reducing investments in companies with poor practices.
If you have ideas on what the CalPERS Board should be doing for members and beneficiaries, please call send me an e-mail at firstname.lastname@example.org. If we can identify just one or two members at each department, board, office, campus, union, or association chapter interested enough in the issues to spend just a few minutes each month, we can accomplish a great deal.
CalPERS Legal Resources from PERSwatch.net (much below needs updated)
- California Assembly
- California Constitution
- California Code of Regulations
- California Senate
- California Statutes (searchable)
- CalPERS Legislation, Regulations & Statutes
- Legislative Counsel
- Petition of 7/24/06 re Uncodified CalPERS Election Regulations
- Connell vs CalPERS
- Westly vs CalPERS 105 Cal. App. 4th 1095; 130 Cal. Rptr. 2d 149; 2003 Cal. App.
- 2007 OAL Determination No. 1 in which the Office of Administrative Law finds the CalPERS Notice of Election contains underground regulations.
- 1999 OAL Determination No. 18 in which Office of Administrative Law finds three CalPERS Board resolutions are “regulations” which must be adopted in accordance with the APA in order to be valid. 1999_OAL_Determination_No._18 (archived version).
- Legislative Counsel Opinion regarding use of State property during CalPERS Campaigns
- American Association of Retired Person (AARP)
- American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME)
- Asian/Pacific State Employees Association (APSEA)
- Association of California State Supervisors (ACSS)
- California Alliance for Retired Americans (CARA)
- California Association of Professional Scientists (CAPS)
- California Association of Highway Patrolmen (CAHP)
- California Association of Psychiatric Technicians (CAPT)
- California Attorneys, Administrative Law Judges and Hearing (CASE)
- California Correctional Peace Officers Association (CCPOA)
- CDF Firefighters
- California Faculty Association (CFA)
- California School Employees Association (CSEA)
- California State Park Peace Officers Association (SPPOAC)
- California State Retirees (CSR)
- California State University Emeritus and Retired Faculty Association (CSU-ERFA)
- California State University Employees Union (CSUEU)
- California Statewide Law Enforcement Association (CSLEA)
- Capital Stewardship Program – AFL-CIO
- International Union of Operating Engineers (IUOE)
- Paywatch (AFL-CIO)
- Professional Engineers in California Government (PECG)
- Retired Public Employees Association of California (RPEA)
- Service Employees International Union (SEIU), Local 1000
- Union of American Physicians and Dentists (UAPD)
Links of Interest to CalPERS Members
Links to other sites of interest to CalPERS members follow. Suggest a link.
- American Benefits Council
- Assisted Living State Regulatory Review
- Benefits Checkup
- Benefits & Compensation Solutions
- Benefits-L: Rich ard Hannah
- Compensation and Benefits, open directory
- ERI Economic Research Institute – Salary Survey Data
- Employee Benefits, Compensation and Pension Law
- Employee Benefit Research Institute
- International Foundation of Employee Benefit Plans
- Retiree Health Care: A Growing Cost For Government (Legislative Analyst’s Office)
- Right to Know: Search your HMO’s covered drugs and learn how to choose a health plan.
- Social Security Administration ~ Calculator
- State retirees deserve pre-funding for health care by Barbara LaPlante.
- California Association of Public Retirement Systems
- California Code of Regulations
- CalPERS Board of Administration
- California State Teachers’ Retirement System
- Los Angeles Pension Trustees
- State Association of County Retirement Systems
- CalPERS raises its profile as watchdog: Giant pension fund sets up office to handle corporate-governance issues
- Corporate Governance
- Council of Institutional Investors
- Ending The Wall Street Walk: Why Corporate Governance Now?
- Fiduciary Responsibilities For Proxy
- American Association of Individual Investors
- Informed Investors Forum
- Investor Protection Trust
- Investors’ Rights Association of America
- Motley Fool
- The Online Investor
- Proxy Democracy
- About Mutual Funds
- Brill’s Mutual Fund’s Interactive
- BusinessWeek Mutual Fund Scoreboard
- CNNMoney Mutual Funds
- Fund Democracy, by former SEC attorney, Mercer Bullard
- Fund Industry Discussion Forum
- Independent Directors Council
- Investment Company Institute
- Links to Mutual Fund Related Websites
- Management Practice Inc., Mutual Fund Governance and Trustee Compensation
- MarketWatch, Mutual Funds/ETFs
- Mutual Fund Investor’s Center
- Mutual Fund Market News
- Mutual Fund Observer and Discussion Board
- Proxy Democracy – rates funds and provides proxy advice to the masses
- CNNMoney.com: Retirement
- Retirement News
- State Worker Blog (Jon Ortiz, Sacramento Bee)
- topix.net Retirement News
- Yahoo! Finance Retirement News Archive
- American Association of Retired Persons
- Association of BellTel RetireesInstitutional Links and Pension Funds
- National Conference on Public Employee Retirement Systems
- National Retiree Organization
- Pension Research Council
- Pension Rights Center
- California State Teachers’ Retirement SystemEmployees Retirement System of Texas (ERS)
- Government Pension Fund (GPF), Royal Thai Government (RTG)
- Florida State Board of Administration
- Insight Investment see especially Engagement and voting
- Los Angeles City Employees’ Retirement System (LACERS)
- New York State Teacher’s Retirement System
- Ohio Public Employees Retirement System
- Ontario Municipal Employees Retirement System (OMERS)
- State Association of Retirement Systems (SACRS) California funds
- State of Wisconsin Investment Board
- TIAA CREF
- Boettner Center for Pensions and Retirement Research (Wharton)
- Center for Retirement Research (Boston College)
- NBER Retirement Research Center
- Retirement Research Center (University of Michigan)
- Retirement Research Foundation
- All Government Agencies
- Bureau of Labor Statistics
- Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services
- Internal Revenue Service
- Medicare Assistance for Seniors
- Medicare/Medicaid Program Manuals
- Securities and Exchange Commission
- SEC – Center for Complaints and Enforcement Tips
- SEC – Investor Advisory Committee
- SEC – Office of Investor Education and Advocacy
- SEC – Proxy Matters
- Social Security Information
- THOMAS; Legislative information