Archive | News

sec-back-door-cartoon

The SEC’s Back Door Around Shareholder Proposals

Today I filed a supplemental comment in the SEC’s Rule 14a-8 rescission proceeding (File No. S7-2026-32). It endorses the request in Rick Alexander’s comment letter. He asks the Commission to withdraw the rescission and to clarify that Rule 14a-8(i)(1) does not let state law or a company’s bylaws exclude nonbinding proposals that otherwise meet the […]

Continue Reading · 0
Executive Order Creates Strong Wind

Executive Order 14366 Rule 14a-8 Rescission

When the SEC proposed rescinding Rule 14a-8, the obvious question was why now? In 2020, the Commission amended the rule. In 2021 and 2023, it told federal courts it had full authority to regulate shareholder proposals. Then, in September 2026, it said the opposite. Part of the answer is in a footnote of the proposing […]

Continue Reading · 0
Bar chart of 2,075 company adoptions of governance reforms: 18% followed a winning shareholder vote; 58% came at companies never targeted.

The Value of Shareholder Proposals Goes Far Beyond the Vote

The SEC’s proposal to rescind Rule 14a-8 (File No. S7-2026-32) rests on a simple measure: roughly 90 percent of voted shareholder proposals fail, so most must not reflect broadly shared concerns. Yesterday, I filed a supplemental comment (add URlL when posted) McRitchie_S7-2026-32_Market_Data_2026-11-12_v9 submitted testing that measure against Diligent Market Intelligence (DMI) records. It was not […]

Continue Reading · 0
Employee Assembly to Study Partial Employee Ownership at PANW

Employee Assembly to Study Partial Employee Ownership at PANW

I recently listened to Freakonomics Radio: Does Democracy Really Need Elections? In it, Stephen Dubner examines sortition, the ancient Athenian practice of filling public bodies by lottery rather than election. The episode is about government. As someone who has filed shareholder proposals since 2000, I kept hearing a description of corporate governance. It also gave […]

Continue Reading · 0
Rule 14a-8 rescission grace period

Heritage Wants a Rule 14a-8 Rescission Grace Period: Use It to Fix Review at the SEC

Stefan Padfield and Allen Mendenhall of The Heritage Foundation have responded on the Harvard Law School Forum to Sarah Wilson’s essay Rule 14a-8: Perhaps There’s Another Way. In Rule 14a-8: Perhaps Slow-Walking Recission is Best, they say Wilson’s account of Heritage’s position “warrant[s] some clarification.” Their answer: Heritage wants a “generous grace period” before Rule […]

Continue Reading · 0
18th-century engraving of Geneva, a republic whose citizens held sovereignty in law but not in practice.

Shareholder Sovereignty in Name Only: Geneva’s Lesson

My friend David Craig Mead-Fox concludes his series on the preservation and spread of democratic knowledge with a story every shareholder should know. On June 19, 1762, Geneva’s Small Council ordered Rousseau’s The Social Contract torn and burned in front of city hall. The irony is that Geneva was a republic whose citizens were, in […]

Continue Reading · 0
Infographic: At Meta and News Corp, majorities of independent shareholders supported proposals that insiders’ super-voting shares defeated; costs followed, including Meta’s $942 million New Mexico judgment and $18 billion settlement. Rescinding Rule 14a-8 would remove this warning channel at all companies.

Controlled Companies Provide a Warning on Rule 14a-8

Update, October 19, 2026: This post has been replaced. After I filed my supplemental comment letter with the SEC, I rewrote it with additional companies, corrected figures and the full evidence. Please read the current version: Controlled Companies Warn the SEC: My Comment on Rule 14a-8. Links to the letter and exhibits on the SEC’s […]

Continue Reading ·
anthropic-governance-control-vs-consensus

Anthropic Governance: The Case for Consensus Over Control

Thanks to Evan Epstein for his thoughtful Who Controls Anthropic? (Boardroom Governance Newsletter #81, October 6, 2026). As Anthropic prepares for what could be one of the largest IPOs in history, Epstein rightly argues that the most important question is not valuation, revenue or competition with OpenAI. It is who will control the company. Thanks […]

Continue Reading ·
default-shareholder-voting-explainer

Default Shareholder Voting: Matt Levine Gets It Wrong

I find most of Matt Levine‘s Money Stuff columns informative, rational, and often witty. Part of his October 1 piece, Default shareholder voting, is an exception. Levine defends the programs at ExxonMobil, Goldman Sachs, and Tesla that let retail investors have their shares voted with the board automatically, at every meeting, until they opt out. […]

Continue Reading ·
Ownership for Real

Ownership: This Time for Real

In 1953 the New York Stock Exchange launched “Own Your Share of American Business,” the longest marketing campaign in its history. As Janice Traflet documents in A Nation of Small Shareholders: Marketing Wall Street after World War II (see my review essay), the campaign had two purposes. It would restore profits to retail brokerage, and […]

Continue Reading ·
One Click one-way-voting

One click. Every vote. One direction. Retail voting programs let shareholders choose only one standing instruction: vote with the board.

Retail voting programs let shareholders choose only one standing instruction: vote with the board. Click below to hear our song about Tesla’s One Click One Way SEC-Approved Voting. One-Way Voting: a “convenience” that points in only one direction SEC staff issued a no-action letter clearing Tesla’s “Issuer Voluntary Retail Voting Program.” Retail holders who opt […]

Continue Reading ·
CalPERS Fossil-Fuel Private Equity- Time for a Scorecard

CalPERS Fossil-Fuel Private Equity: Time for a Scorecard

A new analysis of private equity oil-and-gas funds raises an important question for CalPERS: What has the pension system actually earned from CalPERS fossil-fuel private equity investments after fees, inflation, illiquidity, and risk? As many readers know, I am a retired California State employee, sometimes actively engaged with CalPERS, which provides my pension, and with […]

Continue Reading ·
My Years Inside the Harvard Divestment Fight

My Years Inside the Harvard Divestment Fight

Getting Involved: Tellus, RI@Harvard, and Divest Harvard I first became involved with investment activism in 2011, after the director of my union local hired Joshua Humphreys of the Tellus Institute (at the offices of which, students and advisors met in 2013) to analyze the fundamentals of Harvard Management Company’s practices. This consultancy occurred because Harvard […]

Continue Reading ·
SEC Proposes to Rescind Rule 14a-8

SEC Proposes to Rescind Rule 14a-8: Initial Comments

The SEC has proposed to Rescind Rule 14a-8 would be one of the most consequential changes to shareholder rights in generations. Complete rescission of Rule 14a-8, woiuld repeal the federal rule that has allowed qualifying shareholders to place proposals in company proxy materials for more than 80 years. Under Release No. 34-106383, File No. S7-2026-32, […]

Continue Reading ·
Rule 14a-8 recission and 2026 shareholder proposal trends

Weekend Read: 09/13/2026

ISS STOXX Governance Research released its report “2026 U.S. Proxy Season in Focus: Shareholder Proposals” on July 30. A more readable version was also published on September 2 at the Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance. It is worth reading closely, since it supplies empirical evidence that mainstream institutional investors will rely on to […]

Continue Reading ·
Morningstar’s PANW Report Strengthens Case for Studying Broad-Based Employee Ownership

Morningstar’s PANW Report and Competitive Advantages: Strengthens Case for Studying Broad-Based Employee Ownership

Palo Alto Networks is doing extremely well, according to Morningstar’s PANW Report (view). That may be one of the better reasons—not an argument against—to ask its Board to study whether broader employee ownership could make an already strong company more durable. Morningstar’s September 2 report on Palo Alto Networks (PANW) does not discuss my shareholder […]

Continue Reading ·
Individual Investors Drive Corporate Governance Reform

Individual Investors Drive Corporate Governance Reform Through the Proxy Process

Individual investors who file shareholder proposals have played a significant and consequential role in advancing sound corporate governance. Yet their contribution is often overlooked. Recent debate over the shareholder proposal process has drawn strong responses from institutional investors, faith-based investors, and pension funds seeking to protect shareholders’ ability to engage companies through proposals. Missing from […]

Continue Reading ·
Shared Capital & Exec Pay Restraint

From Executive Pay Restraint to Shared Capital: A Framework for Reforming §162(m)

This article proposes a new federal tax architecture grounded in Shared Capital — a model that links executive deductibility to meaningful employee ownership. For more than thirty years, federal tax law has attempted—unsuccessfully—to restrain executive compensation through §162(m), which limits the deductibility of remuneration paid by publicly held corporations. The current statute prohibits deductions for […]

Continue Reading ·
Corporations shouldn't be unaccountable. The SEC should protect investors, not entrenched management.

Investors Mobilize to Defend Rule 14a-8

State treasurers and investor advocates mobilize to defend Rule 14a-8, which has allowed them to file advisory shareholder proposals since 1942. Dismantling the shareholder-proposal process would silence an essential early-warning system, increase litigation, and shift power from shareholders to corporate management. Jump to How to Defend Rule 14a-8.  Jump to Petition on SEC Rule 14a-8 […]

Continue Reading ·
Broad‑Based Employee Ownership Transactions

Broad‑Based Employee Ownership Transactions

Over the coming months, my wife and I will ask several companies to conduct Board‑supervised studies of whether substantial, non‑controlling, broad‑based employee ownership transactions could strengthen long‑term alignment, productivity, succession, culture, and stockholder value—while preserving Board authority and public‑market discipline. This is a strategic ownership question, not a compensation or benefits request. Our stockholder proposals […]

Continue Reading ·
CorpGov.net 2026 Spring Proxy Season Results 

Proxy Season: Strong Performance for McRitchie

Proxy Season: Governance Still Wins Proxy Season results for James McRitchie so far in spring 2026 look remarkably similar to our strong 2025 season. Last year, we filed 20 proposals directly, losing five and winning fifteen, mostly through agreements. This year, based on results to date, we again show 15 wins, with 4 losses and […]

Continue Reading ·
John Chevedden on Stretching Rule 14a-8

John Chevedden’s 2026 Proposals Show How Far Some Companies Are Stretching Rule 14a-8

Stretching Rule 14a-8. The SEC’s suspension of its decades-long Rule 14a-8 no-action process has created a predictable result: some companies are taking far greater liberties in excluding shareholder proposals. Without the discipline of a substantive SEC staff response, company letters have become more aggressive, less carefully reasoned, and, in several cases, difficult to reconcile with […]

Continue Reading ·

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes