Today I filed a supplemental comment in the SEC’s Rule 14a-8 rescission proceeding (File No. S7-2026-32). It endorses the request in Rick Alexander’s comment letter. He asks the Commission to withdraw the rescission and to clarify that Rule 14a-8(i)(1) does not let state law or a company’s bylaws exclude nonbinding proposals that otherwise meet the Rule. (click for audio version)
This may sound like a technical point. I think it may matter more than the rescission itself. Investors could win the rescission fight and still lose Rule 14a-8, one state statute or one board-adopted bylaw at a time.
The proposing release reads the “proper subject” exclusion in paragraph (i)(1) to cover ownership thresholds set by state law or a company’s governing documents. It even reaches outright bans on precatory proposals. That reading appears in a few pages of a release that is about something else. Commenters are naturally focused on whether the SEC should rescind the Rule at all.
Seen in that order, the rescission release looks like the third attempt to deliver the same result. The speech invited companies. The staff carve-out invited no-action requests. Neither worked. The release now lays out the theory in the Commission’s own words and sets the stage for states to act.
Rescission is the hard path. A final rule needs an economic analysis that survives review under Business Roundtable v. SEC (2011). It faces likely litigation, and a later Commission can reverse it. A reinterpretation is easier, and it survives if rescission dies:
To be fair, the Chairman has never hidden his view. Some will say the release just describes how state law already interacts with the Rule. But the issue is the vehicle, not secrecy. The release reverses decades of practice under the Note to (i)(1), which presumes precatory proposals are proper. It does that inside a proposal whose headline is something else, with no separate economic analysis of who would lose access. An agency that changes course must acknowledge the change and explain it (FCC v. Fox; Encino Motorcars). A few sentences in a rescission release do neither.
States and companies should be free to give shareholders more access to the company proxy, but not less. A federal disclosure requirement that any legislature or board can switch off is not a federal requirement.
My full letter is below. If you haven’t filed yet, the comment period has closed, but the Commission is still receiving letters. Tell the SEC that (i)(1) is a test of subject, not a state-law exit from the Rule.
Download theMcRitchie_S7-2026-32_Supplemental_14a-8i1_2026-11-21 PDF
Linkedin
BlueSky
Facebook
Mastodon
Substack
X (formerly Twitter)
When the SEC proposed rescinding Rule 14a-8, the obvious question was why now? In 2020,…
When I started filing shareholder proposals in 2000, the hostile tender offer was already fading.…
The SEC's proposal to rescind Rule 14a-8 (File No. S7-2026-32) rests on a simple measure:…
I recently listened to Freakonomics Radio: Does Democracy Really Need Elections? In it, Stephen Dubner…
A new Harvard Law School Forum post by Anteris Advisors describes how AI is becoming…
On December 8, Palo Alto Networks (PANW) shareholders will vote on Proposal 6, which asks…