I find most of Matt Levine‘s Money Stuff columns informative, rational, and often witty. Part of his October 1 piece, Default shareholder voting, is an exception. Levine defends the programs at ExxonMobil, Goldman Sachs, and Tesla that let retail investors have their shares voted with the board automatically, at every meeting, until they opt out.
His reasoning: inattentive retail holders probably trust management anyway, so “let the board decide” may capture their unexpressed wishes better than “let the shareholders who show up decide.” Levine’s charm quickly wore off with that.
I see at least four problems with his arguments, plus a fifth that Levine never considers: easy alternatives already exist.
1. Not voting is not consent to management
Today, if you don’t vote, the shareholders who do vote decide. Levine guesses that nonvoters trust management. Maybe. But that is a guess turned into a default, and the companies setting the default are the ones who benefit. Levine quotes Bloomberg’s own reporting that Goldman’s program “is likely to increase turnout in a way that boosts support for the company’s position on key proposals,” coming a year after its pay plan nearly failed. That is the purpose, not a side effect.
2. Management grades its own exam
The board’s “recommendation” covers its own reelection and its own pay. A standing instruction routes uncast votes to the party with the clearest conflict of interest. Shareholder voting exists to check that party, not to rubber-stamp it.
3. One option on the menu is not a choice
Levine dismisses the argument that “vote against the board” or “follow guidelines I select” should also be offered. Why? If the goal is participation, offer neutral options. BlackRock and Vanguard already let many fund investors choose among voting policies. When the only standing option favors the issuer, the program is a turnout machine for one side.
4. Votes are cast before anyone reads the proxy
Tesla’s own request to the SEC says program votes are submitted when the definitive proxy statement is filed, “before the distribution of the definitive proxy statement to shareholders.” Enroll in 2026, and your shares can be voted on in 2029 on proposals that did not exist when you signed up. SEC Rule 14a-4(d) bars a proxy from conferring authority for more than one meeting for exactly this reason. Under Tesla’s program you could be voting on something you never imagined would be an issue.
And no, the SEC did not “grant Tesla permission,” as Levine puts it. Staff said only that it would not recommend enforcement, adding that “this response does not express any legal conclusion on the questions presented.” Courts, not SEC staff, decide what the rules mean.
5. The easy alternative already exists
The implicit premise of Levine’s column is that retail investors face a choice between doing nothing and doing a lot of homework, so default shareholder voting with the board is the only realistic shortcut. That premise is wrong.
iconik is not much more difficult than defaulting to Tesla’s board. The impatient can choose, in 30 to 60 seconds, to vote like an organization they trust, such as As You Sow, Third Act, The Sierra Club Foundation, or the National Center for Public Policy Research. Those choices span the political spectrum. That is the point: the investor picks, not the company.
Those wanting more control can use iconik’s Vote Forge feature. Answer a couple of questions and get a voting policy built on your own priorities, or work through a much more comprehensive set that could take an hour. See a few examples. Many users start with the minimum and get more involved over time, as they see how their votes make a difference. Some are lucky to have advisors who utilize iconik’s tools to show clients how their votes compare to an ETF fund’s, for example.
The major difference between iconikapp.com and Tesla’s program is not the difficulty. It is distribution. iconik users must seek it out on the internet. Tesla, directly or through brokers and “Hubs” such as Robinhood, will reach out to its shareholders with an email and a one-click enrollment. The only standing instruction most retail investors will ever be offered is the one that hands their votes to the people they are supposed to be overseeing.
Where Levine is right, and why it cuts the other way
Levine closes by predicting that AI agents will let retail investors vote on everything cheaply. Exactly. If voting is becoming effortless, the case for handing votes to management by default gets weaker, not stronger. Tools like iconikapp.com show that informed, values-based voting is already nearly as easy as deferring to the board. We should build and promote tools that help owners express their own views, not programs that presume they have none.
Collaborate with CorpGov.net on Social Media (or Leave Comments at the bottom)
Linkedin
BlueSky
Facebook
Mastodon
Substack
X (formerly Twitter)
Default Shareholder Voting: Related Posts

Comments are closed.