Just Investing Podcast

Just Investing Podcast: Jim McRitchie

Just Investing Podcast

United Church Funds introduced a brand-new podcast, “Just Investing,” to tackle big questions in responsible investing. The Podcast, hosted by Matthew Illian and Adam Sank, will feature “powerhouse guests,” who are some of the voices leading the charge for a future in which every investment is a step toward a better world. This post introduces you to this essential new Podcast and provides some additional material from me after listening to my interview in the third episode.

1st Podcast

The first Podcast featured Courtney Wicks, who discusses ExxonMobil’s historical connection to enslaved labor and highlights the critical work of Investor Advocates for Social Justice (IASJ).

2nd Podcast

In the second Just Investing podcast, the Supreme Court reverses decades-long regulatory rules, and Adam and Matthew discuss what that means for responsible investors. Plus, California pushes back on plastic pollution. Nadira Narine from the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility (ICCR) highlights the fight for workers’ rights – from living wages to the right to unionize.

3rd Podcast

I compiled the following notes before and after my appearance on the Just Investing podcast. I hope listeners find the additional information and links helpful.

Just Investing Podcast: Episode 3 on Gadflies

I was initially inspired by Tim Smith of ICCR and their work against apartheid in South Africa. Mark Latham of VoterMedia.org wrote and helped me with my first shareholder proposals in 1999. Neither would be considered gadflies. Of course, the Gilbert brothers established the right of shareholders to file proposals. During the Podcast, Matt mentioned Wilma Soss. I highly recommend Fearless: Wilma Soss and America’s Forgotten Investor Movement.

However, if it comes down to the one gadfly who influenced me most, it has to be John Chevedden. He’s filed over 100 proposals in most years since I met him. He has been invaluable in steering me to important topics and helping me write and file resolutions. Like John, my initial emphasis has been on Governance, the G in ESG, and I suppose it has continued to be.

We believe proper, much more democratic governance will address the E & S symptoms of poor management. However, over time, we have both recognized that we can’t wait for more democratic governance. Shareholders must address many issues simultaneously to ensure a salubrious environment and a democratic civil society.

ICCR Membership

That was an exciting second Just Investing Podcast. I didn’t know that Nadira had started at ICCR 20 years ago. She is a fine example of the expert help available through ICCR.

I was essentially drafted into ICCR. ICCR wanted better coordination with gadflies because we were filing so many proposals. Let’s ensure we aren’t filing the same or conflicting proposals at the same companies. At that time, I was running my website as a business, so I was able to come in as an organization. Of course, I was honored to join.

As to what they are doing well, I mentioned that ICCR and Tim Smith have strongly influenced my thinking for about 50 years. Over that time, ICCR has undoubtedly evolved and has been able to hire more experts in human rights, climate change, worker’s rights, etc. They even have committees facilitating advocacy at individual companies, such as Amazon.

With most companies moving to virtual annual meetings, which do not provide mechanisms for shareholders to meet with each other or with company employees (although they could), I see a growing role for ICCR in bringing shareholder proponents at companies together with workers, customers, and the public to discuss and promote proposals.

I like that ICCR itself operates very cooperatively and democratically. It doesn’t file proposals, but it certainly helps its members file. As I get older and less willing to spend as much time on research and filing, I rely more on their expertise to keep up with the issues. For example, I’m already working with Tim Smith on a few lobbying proposals for next year. It certainly helps me to have him on the Zoom call when negotiating with companies since Tim knows more about what other companies have agreed to regarding disclosures and how company disclosure disagreements with trade associations.

Just Investing Podcast: Impact of State of California Career

For many years, I headed legislative or rulemaking functions, sometimes both. The primary battles I witnessed were those between companies in writing the laws and regulations. Members of the legislature had little expertise, and the department felt captured. One meeting at the capitol struck me. About a dozen of us were drafting a fee bill to support my department. Almost everyone in the room was a high-paid attorney/lobbyist. Oil, transportation, hazardous waste facilities, trade associations, and one inexperienced representative of a public interest group were there.

Aside from reaching an agreement on the terms of the bill and how much each industry would have to pay for regulation, industry attorneys wrote the bill with as much complexity as possible so those wanting to take advantage of various exemptions or even be able to comply would be wise to hire someone in that room to help them understand the bill.

There was and is a power imbalance. I knew that when I took the job. Years before that meeting, I had written legislation to address the needs of people who lost their immunity and their lives due to chemical exposures. Although AB 3587 (1984) passed through both chambers, the bill was vetoed by the governor at the request of two CMAs: the Chemical Manufacturing Association and, more surprisingly, the California Medical Association. They didn’t want to recognize an illness they didn’t know how to treat.

Anyway, I resolved that if I couldn’t regulate or even satisfactorily influence companies by authoring legislation or as an executive at Cal/EPA, maybe I could do so as a shareholder.

Squelching the Influence of Small Investors

Like Arjuna and Follow This, John and I were sued by several companies (Waste Connections, EMC, Omnicom, Express Scripts, Chipotle). Unlike those recent proponents, we didn’t face our well-resourced companies head-on. Instead, we pledged not to sue them if they left our proposals off the ballot. According to a Supreme Court ruling, those pledges took away any standing companies that had to sue us. Federal courts in Texas disagreed but didn’t award court costs to the companies, which could have amounted to hundreds of thousands to pay corporate attorneys. Massachusetts, New York, and Colorado courts agreed with us and dismissed the cases. They awarded us court costs, but since we represented ourselves, we didn’t file for them… or at least I didn’t.

More recently, under leadership appointed by Donald Trump, the SEC raised the submission and resubmission requirements for filing proposals. The rules were based on inflated estimates submitted by industry of the cost of proposals. The Commission said there was no way to accurately determine the benefits of proposals, even though several of us submitted evidence to the contrary. The benefits far outweigh the costs. Our June 2021 lawsuit against the rulemaking is still pending in the DC district. Trump is widely expected to appoint Hester Peirce to chair the SEC. That will probably lead to stricter rules or higher thresholds for shareholders to submit proposals, particularly those related to environmental, social, and governance (ESG) issues.

Just Investing Podcast: Last Words

In 2012, a relatively obscure bureaucrat initiated a mandate that Denmark’s corporate boards include at least 40% women. The same ministry requires daycare and maternity/paternity leave. These were just good policies for a healthy society.

However, when that movement came to the United States, because fiduciary duty is interpreted here as a mandate to put profits first, advocates of more women on boards were compelled to find studies linking increased female directors to greater profitability.

A more recent example of how the concept of fiduciary duty has imposed unreasonable limits on human development was an opinion rendered in Delaware earlier this year (McRitchie v Zukerberg). The court found that corporate directors have a fiduciary duty to the company and its shares; the shareholders are “incidental.”

In other words, shares have become reified, treated as concrete things with rights separate from people and in a way that vests them with a higher authority than their owners. The world becomes very dangerous when our creations have more rights than we do collectively as living sentient beings. Fiduciary duty must be redefined and grounded in the values of real human beings, not on the false assumption that our highest value is greed, with little consideration of future generations or the natural world.

Investing and stewardship must be based on shared concepts of justice. From the name of your Podcast and listening to the first episode, I know you share that concern. Thanks for inviting me to share my thoughts and experiences with you and your audience.

As an avid listener of the Just Investing Podcast, I look forward to your insights.

 Linkedin  

Just Investing: Related Posts

TheCorporateCounsel.net Podcast: Jim McRitchie on Retail Investor Activism

About

What Does It Profit Podcast

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments are closed.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes