Exxon Vote Capture

Exxon Vote Capture

Exxon Vote Capture: approved. They applied for a no-action letter from the SEC Staff. It won approval on the same day. It is disheartening that Staff of a government agency would condone corporate vote rigging by authorizing the violation of the rules.

Under Rule 14a-4(d)(2), “no proxy shall confer authority […] [t]o vote at any annual meeting other than the next annual meeting (or any adjournment thereof) to be held after the date on which the proxy statement and form of proxy are first sent or given to security holders.” Under a similar provision, Rule 14a-4(d)(3) provides that “no proxy shall confer authority […] [t]o vote with respect to more than one meeting (and any adjournment thereof).” 17 CFR 240.14a-4.

Exxon argued its “proposed Retail Voting Program should not be viewed as conflicting with Rules 14a-4(d)(2) or 14a-4(d)(3),” given “reminders and easy opt.” Do SEC Staff now have the authority to pre-authorize violations of the rules?

Exxon’s auto‑voting program for retail shareholders allows investors to “opt in” so that their shares are automatically voted in line with management’s recommendations. While Exxon frames the move as a way to “ensure your voice is heard” and make proxy voting easier for retail investors, the real effect is to tilt the corporate governance playing field heavily in favor of the incumbent board by capturing 40% of Exxon’s stock, which retail investors own.

Exxon Vote Capture: Historical Background

Most readers are too young to remember. This move is similar to what was proposed by Stephen Norman (corporate secretary at American Express, Chair and CEO of the Society for Corporate Governance, and member of the NYSE proxy working group) in 2006, two weeks after the NYSE filed a proposal with the SEC to eliminate all broker voting in the election of directors. That speed was not a coincidence. I wrote about Q&A on Client-Directed Voting and provided testimony to the SEC. Norman, at least, would have given shareholders options. Shareholders could choose to vote:  (1) in proportion to other retail shareholders; (2) in a manner consistent with the board’s recommendation; or (3) in a manner that is contrary to the board’s recommendation. Exxon’s plan for capturing the vote is straightforward: vote automatically with management or abstain from voting automatically.

We successfully held them back for 19 years. Under Trump, corporations now see an opportunity to seize control of proxies from unsuspecting shareholders. Retail vote capture won’t stop with XOM. There will be a flood of requests from other companies. Davis Polk & Wardwell LLP helped Exxon. Five days later, Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP posted to the Harvard corpgov blog, Exxon’s Auto-Voting Plan: Implications for Shareholder Activism and Considerations for Companies.

These types of vote capture efforts should be opposed. Instead, please support true choice voting through iconikapp.com and other platforms that allow retail investors to automatically vote using proxy voting policies developed by organizations such as As You Sow, Stand.earth, Third Act, the Sierra Club Foundation, or the National Center for Public Policy Research. Suppose you disagree with how they vote on specific issues. In that case, you can use their policies with modifications, or you can use Vote Forge to quickly build your own customized proxy voting policies by answering a series of questions.

Exxon Vote Capture: As You Sow and the Interfaith Center for Corporate Responsibility Took Action

As You Sow and the Interfaith Center for Corporate Responsibility (ICCR) filed a request with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to rescind its effective approval of ExxonMobil’s “Retail Voting Program.” Exxon’s program, under the guise of ‘assisting’ retail voters, seeks to opt retail shareholders into a program that would cast their votes in favor of management for all future meetings, unless and until shareholders take steps to opt out.

Rule 14a-4, however, states that authority to vote on behalf of a shareholder cannot be given for more than a single annual meeting, with voting materials furnished in advance of giving such authority. SEC’s 14a-4 proxy voting rules were promulgated to ensure that shareholders who have invested their capital have an effective voice in company management. Exxon’s plan does the opposite.

Said Andrew Behar, CEO of As You Sow:

This program is a direct attack on shareholder rights. Currently, retail voters hold roughly 40% of Exxon shares, and nearly 75% of those shareholders currently do not vote. A standing proxy in favor of management, therefore, significantly increases the odds of a perpetual management advantage. This goal is underscored by the fact that Exxon fails to make available an equivalent standing vote against management.

Josh Zinner, CEO of ICCR noted:

Rules like 14a-4 are crucial for ensuring that the powerful corporate players in our economy remain accountable to their stakeholders and positioned for long-term success. Under Exxon’s proposed program, retail investors would relinquish their rights to evaluate the company’s performance annually and cast their votes accordingly, thereby potentially granting management carte blanche on critical governance issues, such as contested board contests, CEO pay votes, and other matters. The Exxon scheme assumes that investors prefer to be passive when what is clearly needed to ensure successful companies are more engaged, active investors.

Danielle Fugere, President & Chief Counsel of As You Sow

Exxon’s violation of current SEC proxy rules is not a technical footnote. Although Exxon equates its program to existing third-party voting guidelines, like “As You Vote,” its program is fundamentally different. As You Vote and a range of other 3rd party voting guidelines apply to all companies, and there is no self-interested vote as with Exxon’s scheme. The securities laws are clear — proxies must be given annually, after investors receive the meeting-specific issues on which they will be voting. Exxon’s retail voter program blatantly ignores those requirements. Allowing this program to proceed would set a dangerous precedent that undermines the integrity of our markets.

CONTACT: Ryon Harms, ryon@asyousow.org, (310) 730-9407

About As You Sow (AYS). As You Sow is the nation’s leading shareholder representative, with a 30+ year track record promoting environmental and social corporate responsibility. Its focus areas include climate change, ocean plastics, toxins in the food system, the Rights of Nature, racial justice, and workplace diversity. Click here to view As You Sow’s shareholder resolution tracker.

About the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility (ICCR). The Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility (ICCR) is a broad coalition of more than 300 institutional investors collectively representing over $4 trillion in invested capital. ICCR members, a cross-section of faith-based investors, asset managers, pension funds, foundations, and other long-term institutional investors, have over 50 years of experience engaging with companies on environmental, social, and governance (“ESG”) issues that are critical to long-term value creation. ICCR members engage with hundreds of corporations annually to foster greater corporate accountability. Visit our website www.iccr.org and follow us on LinkedIn and Bsky.

Collaborate with CorpGov.net on Social Media (or Leave a Reply at the bottom)

Linkedin
BlueSky
Facebook
Mastodon
Substack
X (formerly Twitter)

Exxon Vote Capture: Related Posts

An Open Proposal for Client Directed Voting

Retail Shareholder Proxy Participation: Part 2 – CDV

Standing Voting Instructions: Reviewed

Proxy Season 2021 Investor Sentiment Study: Action Needed

 

 

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments are closed.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes