A Majority Vote should be required for unopposed corporate directors

Majority Vote Requirements for Directors: Become an Advocate

Majority vote requirements should be the election standard at every company where directors are unopposed. Companies run by authoritarians oppress workers, externalize costs, and support presidents who act like dictators. To ensure a harmonious society and a salubrious environment, support the movement to democratize corporations. Majority Vote Requirements are key. Get that right, and we can elect directors who care about growing our companies and our wealth by engaging employees and operating sustainably.

Majority Vote Requirements: A Threshold Right

The majority vote requirement for unopposed directors is a threshold right that ensures shareholders have at least some degree of say over those who direct the corporations they invest in.  This right could become increasingly important in a world where shareholders’ ability to file precatory (advisory) resolutions or to sue their own companies over alleged mismanagement and other director/officer decisions is increasingly restricted by tightening rules for shareholder derivative lawsuits and by codifying very protective business judgment rules. For example, Texas took the action I warned against.

I’ve been filing shareholder proposals for 25 years. It’s been a rewarding activity. As I approach my eighties, I realize it’s time for a younger generation to take over. In the post below, I discuss the importance of majority vote requirements. Then I’ll provide an example proposal on this topic that I recently submitted to Snowflake, Inc. Finally, I’ll list more than 500 companies where such proposals could be filed and where companies could be transformed with all the brains in the room. In my experience, this is the easiest shareholder proposal to win. The representatives of most companies I have met with understand that reappointing a director who couldn’t even win a majority vote when unopposed is a very bad look, especially if we are still living in a democracy.

Filing majority vote proposals could set you on a course of getting to know the companies you invest in and learning how to shape their corporate governance. Again, learning such skills could become increasingly important as shareholder rights come under attack. See, for example, The SEC, Delaware, and the High Stakes for Investors on Advisory Shareholder Proposals and Investor Rights at Risk. It can also be profitable as you learn more about the companies in your portfolio and adjust your investments accordingly.

Majority Vote Requirements: Why Important

Requiring a majority vote standard in uncontested director elections is foundational to corporate democracy. It ensures that directors earn—not inherit—the right to serve. Without it, a director can be “elected” with a single vote, even if every other shareholder withholds support. That’s not democracy; it’s autocracy in a business suit.

This minimal standard becomes more urgent as shareholder rights are steadily eroded. Courts are narrowing the path for derivative lawsuits. The SEC is restricting the types of shareholder proposals that can appear on proxy ballots. Delaware is actively making it harder to challenge poor governance through procedural hurdles. When other tools for accountability are weakened, the right to meaningfully vote on directors becomes essential.

The case for majority vote requirements isn’t abstract. Over 92% of S&P 500 companies have already adopted this standard, recognizing it as best practice. And support is consistently strong—my own proposals on this issue have averaged 73% support in recent years. Institutional investors like BlackRock and Vanguard agree and typically vote in favor of such proposals.

Majority Vote Requirements: Initial Proposal for Shareholder Advocates

This is a proposal that’s both winnable and impactful. It’s a relatively easy lift for new proponents—ideal for shareholders looking to take their first step into corporate governance advocacy. The mechanics are simple, the ask is reasonable, and the precedent is strong. But the potential ripple effect is enormous: more accountable boards, better oversight, and more companies led by directors who must earn shareholders’ trust.

In a time of democratic backsliding in politics and corporate life, your vote—and your voice—matter more than ever. Filing a proposal for majority vote requirements is one of the most effective ways to ensure that corporate boards serve all shareholders, not just themselves. It’s how we make sure all the brains in the room are engaged—not just the most entrenched.

Majority Vote Requirements: Snowflake, Inc.

I have previously submitted proposals to SnowFlake in 2024 and won 78.3% of the vote, so I should not have any issues providing evidence of ownership. Note: Snowflake did not declassify its board, despite the 2024 vote. In the first example in this series, I filed a proposal to declassify the board of WestBanco, Inc. (WSBC). It turns out that although I owned the predecessor company for many years, the ownership clock reset when two companies recently merged. I have since withdrawn that proposal. There shouldn’t be any issues like that at SnowFlake. Here’s the proposal I submitted to Snowflake, SNOW DMV.  Go back to the post Declassify Boards: Become an Advocate for tips on the transmittal letter and on obtaining and submitting your broker letter, which evidences the required ownership level.

Majority Vote Requirements: Some Companies Without

Here is the promised spreadsheet of more than 500 companies that I believe lack a majority-vote standard for uncontested director elections. (Majority Vote Requirements for Directors Needed) I have ranked them by size, with larger companies at the top. You may want to make a copy and sort it alphabetically.

If you have ever thought about being a shareholder advocate, this is your chance. This is probably one of the easiest types of proposals to file and win. Double-check the bylaws of any company you select off the list, since the company may have updated them… or I could have gotten it wrong. Again, check the latest proxy to learn where to send your proposal after you use my template.

You can find these filings on the SEC’s Electronic Data Gathering, Analysis, and Retrieval (EDGAR) system. I find CapEdge more user-friendly. Both are free. Let me know if you find even better free sites for SEC filings.

Collaborate with CorpGov.net on Social Media (or Leave a Reply at the bottom)

Linkedin
BlueSky
Facebook
Mastodon
Substack
X (formerly Twitter)

Majority Vote Requirements: Related Posts

Special Meetings: Become an Advocate

Proxy Access Needed: Become an Advocate

Declassify Boards: Become an Advocate

With All the Brains in the Room

 

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments are closed.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes