Declassify Boards - Become an Advocate

Declassify Boards: Become an Advocate

Declassify Boards: Join the Fight

Click for 1 minute audio introduction below:

Corporate governance is key. Get that right, and we can elect directors who care about growing our companies and our wealth by engaging employees and operating sustainably. Companies run by dictators oppress workers, externalize costs, and support presidents who act like dictators. To ensure a harmonious society and a salubrious environment, support the movement to democratize corporations.

Especially after Citizens United, it has become increasingly challenging to elect and maintain a democratic government with an economy built around more and more companies run by dictators and oligarchs.

I have been filing corporate governance proposals for 25 years. It was a rewarding activity during retirement, but it is time for a younger generation of shareholders to take over. In the post below, I discuss the importance of each director standing for election every year. Then I’ll provide you with an example of such a proposal and explain the basics of filing. Finally, I’ll list about 500 companies that I believe have classified boards.

Declassify Boards: Why Important

Increased Director Accountability

  • Annual elections allow shareholders to hold all directors accountable every year.
  • With a classified board, only a fraction (typically one-third) of directors stand for election annually, meaning underperforming or misaligned directors may remain on the board for years.
  • Shareholders value the ability to make regular, timely changes in board composition when necessary.

 Improved Corporate Governance Standards

  • Declassified boards are considered a best practice under the corporate governance principles promoted by leading proxy advisors such as ISS, Glass Lewis, Minerva Analytics, PIRC, Frontis Governance, Proxinvest, and Egan-Jones.
  • Many institutional investors, such as BlackRock, Vanguard, Fidelity, and State Street, have proxy voting guidelines that favor annual board elections.

Enhancement of Shareholder Rights

  • A classified board can serve as an entrenchment mechanism, insulating directors and management from shareholder influence.
  • Declassification aligns with efforts to reduce managerial entrenchment and promote shareholder democracy.

More Responsive Boards

  • Directors facing annual elections are more likely to be responsive to shareholder concerns, market conditions, and corporate performance.
  • This is particularly important in activist campaigns or when significant strategic decisions (like M&A) are being evaluated.

Empirical Support for Performance Benefits

  • Research (including studies by academics and groups such as the CFA Institute) suggests that declassified boards are associated with better firm performance, including higher valuation and greater responsiveness to takeovers.
  • Activist investors often push for declassification to unlock value and enhance governance.

Reduced Takeover Defenses

  • A staggered board makes hostile takeovers more difficult, thereby entrenching management, even when a takeover might benefit shareholders.
  • Declassification is often seen as removing a structural anti-takeover defense, giving shareholders a greater voice in corporate control issues.

Growing Momentum & Precedent

  • More than 90% of S&P 500 companies have declassified boards, often in response to shareholder proposals and engagement.
  • The growing number of successful declassification proposals strengthens the normative pressure on companies to follow suit.

Declassify Boards: Example

Transmittal Letter

I’m using as an example (WSBC Transmit redact) a proposal I recently submitted to WestBanco, Inc. (WSBC). I’ve included the transmittal letter and the proposal in that downloadable document. Look at your company’s most recent proxy statement for instructions on where to send proxy proposals and when they are due. You can also telephone the company and request that information. Searching online will often yield the corporate secretary’s name and email address. I generally submit proposals via email, asking them for a quick response. If I don’t get it, I use FedEx and obtain proof of timely delivery. Here’s an internet resource guide. For WSBC, I used FedEx.

When a shareholder submits a proposal under Rule 14a-8, they are required to include in the transmittal letter two specific dates and times when they are available to discuss the proposal by telephone. Those dates must fall between 10 and 30 calendar days after the company receives the proposal.

Caution: Requirements can be updated throughout the year. It is always a good idea to work with an experienced attorney or shareholder advocate. I will try to help if I can, but I will refer you to others or charge a fee if I get many requests.

WestBanco (WSBC) will likely hold its meeting in person in Wheeling, West Virginia, in April, as it did last year. Many, if not most, companies now hold virtual meetings. If that is the case, you can usually present the proposal by phone. If you fail to present your proposal, the company will be permitted to exclude all of your proposals from its proxy materials for any meetings held in the following two calendar years.

Broker Letter

Do not submit a broker letter with your proposal. It must arrive at least 1 day after the proposal and no more than 14 calendar days after you receive a deficiency notice from the company, reminding you that they need evidence of the required ownership. Under SEC Rule 14a-8, shareholders submitting a proposal to be included in a company’s proxy materials must demonstrate proof of ownership of the company’s securities. If the shares are held through a broker or bank (i.e., in “street name”), the shareholder must submit a broker letter (also called a proof of ownership letter). Make sure it is on their stationery. Here’s the request I made to my broker, Charles Schwab. WSBC BL request2026 redacted 

The letter must:

  1. Come from the record holder (a DTC participant, which could be the broker or a bank upstream of the broker),

  2. Confirm that the shareholder held the securities continuously for the required period.

  3. Include the DTC participant number, which is the unique number identifying the bank or broker with The Depository Trust Company (DTC).

Submit that letter request to your broker as soon as you have evidence that the company has received your proposal. Your first request may also be the first request your broker has ever had for such a request, so expect delays. I’ll post a copy of the broker’s letter confirming my ownership of SEBC when it arrives.

I have a Shareowner Action Handbook that needs updating. Look around the web for other resources. ChatGPT has a “Securities & Exchange Lawyer” that can be helpful. However, it can also be very wrong.

Declassify Boards: Some Companies with Classified Boards

Here is the promised spreadsheet of about 500 companies that I believe have classified boards. (Classified Boards) I have ranked them by size, with the largest companies at the top. You may want to make a copy and sort it alphabetically.

If you have ever thought about being a shareholder advocate, this is your chance. This is probably one of the easiest types of proposals to file and win. Double-check the bylaws of any company you select off the list, since the company may have updated them… or I could have gotten it wrong. Again, check the latest proxy to learn where to send your proposal after you use my template.

You can find these filings on the SEC’s Electronic Data Gathering, Analysis, and Retrieval (EDGAR) system. I find CapEdge more user-friendly. Both are free. Let me know if you find even better free sites for SEC filings.

Collaborate with CorpGov.net on Social Media (or Leave a Reply at the bottom)

Linkedin
BlueSky
Facebook
Mastodon
Substack
X (formerly Twitter)

Declassify Boards: Related Posts

Schwab 2025: Declassify the Board

AVAV 2023 AGM: Declassify the Board

nCino 2025: Declassify the Board

Snowflake 2024 Proxy Votes – Declassify the Board

Invitae 2022 Proxy Scorecard 40

Harvard’s Shareholder Rights Project

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments are closed.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes