David Brooks Misreads the Democratic Left

David Brooks Misreads the Democratic Left

David Brooks argues that Donald Trump and the MAGA movement have co-opted the revolutionary playbook of the radical left. His October 2025 column, “Hey, Lefties! Trump Has Stolen Your Game,” is correct that MAGA borrows left-wing rhetorical tools—anti-elitism, distrust of institutions, and even the performance of rebellion. But he misreads what those ideas meant in their original form. By flattening the left’s intellectual traditions into a catalogue of destructive impulses, Brooks overlooks their democratic core. The left has a long lineage of thinkers devoted to liberating human agency and expanding participation in both politics and the economy. That lineage has never been adopted in the US.

David Brooks: MAGA Plays Insurrectionist

Brooks’s genealogy of MAGA’s “borrowed ideas” begins with postmodernism and runs through Marxism, critical theory, identity politics, and cultural struggle. He focuses on left-wing threads that call for tearing institutions apart. Brooks notes the right has absorbed the language of power critique—branding universities, journalists, and public servants as the new “elite.” In this sense, MAGA mimics leftist rhetoric, transforming cries for emancipation into grievances of cultural victimhood. Trump’s “deep state” conspiracy, for example, re-purposes C. Wright Mills’s Power Elite to paint bureaucrats as the enemy of “the people.” Steve Bannon openly embraces Lenin’s idea of a revolutionary vanguard, which Trump now deploys to smash the administrative state, rather than capitalism. Brooks captures this inversion well: the right, once the defender of order, now plays the role of the insurrectionist.

David Brooks: False Assumptions of the Left’s Motivations

Where Brooks goes astray is in treating the left’s intellectual inheritance as nihilistic. The democratic theorists who shaped the modern left—people such as Severyn T. Bruyn, Paul Bernstein, and Carole Pateman—did not seek chaos but participatory reconstruction. Bruyn’s vision of a “moral economy” proposed that democratic values could be extended into the workplace, enabling citizens to exercise responsibility in the places where they spend most of their waking lives. Bernstein’s work on cooperative and worker-owned enterprises reframed socialism as an experiment in economic democracy rather than a project of state domination. Pateman’s Participation and Democratic Theory demonstrated that freedom depends on participation itself—the act of self-government through which people cease being subjects and become citizens. Each of these theorists treated democracy as exponential: its power grows as more people practice it in everyday life.

The left’s motivation, then, has been the liberation of human agency from tyranny and oligarchy, not the replacement of one ruling class with another. The left’s critique of hierarchy aims at inclusion—of workers as well as shareholders in governance, of all people in public life (regardless of demographic characteristics), of all citizens in economic decision-making.

David Brooks: MAGA Embraces Revolt but Reverses the Substance of Left Critique

Where MAGA mimics the gestures of revolt, it reverses the substance: its populism rallies the majority to defend inherited privilege; its “anti-elitism” protects oligarchs who masquerade as outsiders. The left’s theory of emancipation is grounded in solidarity and equality; MAGA’s in resentment and exclusion.

Brooks conflates these very different moral energies when he claims that “leftist ideas now belong to the establishment” and that both sides are revolutionary without constructive ideology. He misses that democracy is the constructive ideology—the continuous project of widening voice and accountability. The left’s institutional critique was never meant to annihilate the rule of law, truth, or reason. It was meant to make those institutions answer to the people they govern. When Trumpists declare “truth isn’t truth” or when they weaponize “cancel culture” to silence dissent, they are not completing the left’s revolution. They are clearly betraying it.

David Brooks Misses the Difference Between Grievance and Emancipation

What Brooks glimpses—but incompletely—is the cultural feedback loop between the radical left’s language of emancipation and the populist right’s theater of grievance. His lament that liberals have “no moderate intellectual tradition to fall back on” ignores the enduring democratic philosophies that animate movements for labor justice, cooperative ownership, and participatory governance. These traditions represent not the failure of the left but its unfinished work. Build an economy and polity in which the exponential power of nurturing democracy replaces domination by tyrants and oligarchs.

CorpGovFavicon

Brooks is right that MAGA has stolen the rhetoric of rebellion. But he is wrong about the soul of the left. The democratic project he mistakes for nihilism remains the most constructive political vision we possess. When everyone is free to participate, society does not collapse; it flourishes on a foundation of democracy. I write primarily about corporate governance because corporations are currently our most influential institutions. We cannot have a democratic government in the United States when corporate governance is based on tyranny and oligarchy, not democracy.

Collaborate with CorpGov.net on Social Media (or Leave a Reply at the bottom)

Linkedin
BlueSky
Facebook
Mastodon
Substack
X (formerly Twitter)

David Brooks: Related Posts

Ending the Wall Street Walk: Why Corporate Governance Now?

Review Essay: Citizens DisUnited

Millennial Socialists Bolstered by SEC

CorpGov Library

Shareowner Action Handbook

About

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments are closed.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes