sec-back-door-cartoon

The SEC’s Back Door Around Shareholder Proposals

Today I filed a supplemental comment in the SEC’s Rule 14a-8 rescission proceeding (File No. S7-2026-32). It endorses the request in Rick Alexander’s comment letter. He asks the Commission to withdraw the rescission and to clarify that Rule 14a-8(i)(1) does not let state law or a company’s bylaws exclude nonbinding proposals that otherwise meet the Rule. (click for audio version)

This may sound like a technical point. I think it may matter more than the rescission itself. Investors could win the rescission fight and still lose Rule 14a-8, one state statute or one board-adopted bylaw at a time.

A Back Door That Stays Open If the Front Door Closes

The proposing release reads the “proper subject” exclusion in paragraph (i)(1) to cover ownership thresholds set by state law or a company’s governing documents. It even reaches outright bans on precatory proposals. That reading appears in a few pages of a release that is about something else. Commenters are naturally focused on whether the SEC should rescind the Rule at all.

Here is the argument that the SEC may have used the rescission release to plant a reinterpretation of (i)(1). That reading would invite states to supersede Rule 14a-8 even if the Commission never adopts the rescission. Look at the order of events:

  • October 9, 2025. At Delaware’s Weinberg Center, Chairman Paul Atkins floated the theory that precatory proposals may not be a “proper subject” under Delaware law and could be excluded under (i)(1). He also suggested companies could adopt bylaws with higher ownership or holding-period thresholds.
  • November 17, 2025. Corporation Finance stopped responding to no-action requests on every basis for exclusion except (i)(1). It singled out the one exclusion the Chairman had just spotlighted.
  • August 14, 2026. The staff ended no-action responses entirely, including under (i)(1). It noted it had received no (i)(1) requests all season. No company had been willing to test the theory before the staff, Delaware counsel opinion in hand.
  • September 16, 2026. The theory reappears. This time it carries the Commission’s own voice in the rescission release, and it is broader. It now reaches state-law and bylaw eligibility thresholds, not just the subject of a proposal.
  • September 2025 and November 2026. Texas already lets listed companies bar proposals from anyone holding less than $1 million or 3 percent, by board action, through Section 21.373. Delaware’s Corporation Law Council has released a discussion draft that would bar precatory proposals at most companies.

Seen in that order, the rescission release looks like the third attempt to deliver the same result. The speech invited companies. The staff carve-out invited no-action requests. Neither worked. The release now lays out the theory in the Commission’s own words and sets the stage for states to act.

Why Put It in a Rescission Release?

Rescission is the hard path. A final rule needs an economic analysis that survives review under Business Roundtable v. SEC (2011). It faces likely litigation, and a later Commission can reverse it. A reinterpretation is easier, and it survives if rescission dies:

  • Interpretive rules can skip notice and comment. Once the reading appears in a release, the Commission can later adopt it as “guidance” and say commenters already had their chance.
  • There is no longer any staff review. Companies now decide exclusions for themselves. A Commission statement that (i)(1) covers state and bylaw thresholds gives them cover to omit proposals. A proponent’s only remedy is a lawsuit, which most retail owners cannot afford.
  • It hands the job to the states. Delaware’s draft is written to take effect only if rescission does. Under the release’s reading of (i)(1), nothing stops Delaware or any other state from dropping that condition. Texas never had one. The Rule itself would then enforce whatever limits the states write.

To be fair, the Chairman has never hidden his view. Some will say the release just describes how state law already interacts with the Rule. But the issue is the vehicle, not secrecy. The release reverses decades of practice under the Note to (i)(1), which presumes precatory proposals are proper. It does that inside a proposal whose headline is something else, with no separate economic analysis of who would lose access. An agency that changes course must acknowledge the change and explain it (FCC v. Fox; Encino Motorcars). A few sentences in a rescission release do neither.

What I Asked the SEC to Do

  1. Withdraw the rescission.
  2. Adopt Mr. Alexander’s clarification now by interpretation, and later by amendment to the Note to (i)(1). Eligibility and procedure belong in paragraphs (b) through (f). State or bylaw thresholds and precatory bans do not make a proposal excludable as an improper subject.
  3. State that such provisions do not affect a company’s federal obligations, under SEC v. Transamerica (3d Cir. 1947): “The power conferred upon the Commission by Congress cannot be frustrated by a corporate by-law.”
  4. If the SEC wants state law to set eligibility, propose that openly as an amendment to paragraph (b), with an economic analysis, and invite comment.

States and companies should be free to give shareholders more access to the company proxy, but not less. A federal disclosure requirement that any legislature or board can switch off is not a federal requirement.

My full letter is below. If you haven’t filed yet, the comment period has closed, but the Commission is still receiving letters. Tell the SEC that (i)(1) is a test of subject, not a state-law exit from the Rule.

My Comment Letter

Download theMcRitchie_S7-2026-32_Supplemental_14a-8i1_2026-11-21 PDF

Collaborate with CorpGov.net on Social Media (or Leave Comments at the bottom)

Linkedin
BlueSky
Facebook
Mastodon
Substack
X (formerly Twitter)

Related Posts

Investors Mobilize to Defend Rule 14a-8

SEC Quorum Rule: A Commission of One, Adopted Without Public Comment

Business Roundtable to SEC: Muzzle Shareholders

SEC Release Comments Due Today

 

, , , , , , , , , ,

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes