Materiality

Materiality: How Will it Change When Determined by Individuals?

Materiality and Its Evolution in Corporate Governance

Materiality was the subject of a post by Sasja Beslik about a year and a half ago. Scrolling through my own draft posts recently, I came upon this brief reflection on his post. Here it is, edited only slightly.  Sasja Beslik, you heightened awareness of the need to focus on what #materiality is. I think it is about to change dramatically.

As you point out, in 1976, Justice Thurgood Marshall wrote in TSC Industries v. Northway that a fact is “material” if there is “a substantial likelihood that a reasonable shareholder would consider it important in deciding how to vote,” or “a substantial likelihood that the disclosure of the omitted fact would have been viewed by the reasonable investor as having significantly altered the ‘total mix’ of information made available.”

Shifts in Equity Ownership and Voting Patterns

With the rise of pensions and retirement accounts, equity shifted from retail to institutions in the last century. Proxy voting by retail plummeted, and institutional voting became routinized. See CII’s Governance Guide: Proxy Voting.

Now, beneficial owners are frustrated. #ESG funds don’t vote for ESG proposals, and red-state officials attack funds that do. Both demand pass-through voting for individuals who don’t have fiduciary duties, free to consider “reasons other than direct financial repercussions.”The Role of Surveys and Technology in Shaping Materiality

The survey questions used by organizations like Just Capital may increasingly shape “materiality.” Platforms like iconikapp facilitate pass-through and, ultimately, individual voting. How much different will “materiality” be when individuals rather than financial institutions determine votes?

The Changing Landscape of Materiality

The concept of materiality is evolving under the pressures of modern investment practices and regulatory changes. Traditionally, materiality in the context of corporate and securities law has been defined by what a reasonable shareholder would consider important for making voting or investment decisions. However, as individual investors gain more influence through pass-through voting mechanisms, the definition of what is considered material may shift to reflect broader concerns, including environmental, social, and governance (ESG) issues.

Conclusion

Integrating individual voting through technological advancements and the increasing influence of ESG considerations will likely redefine materiality in corporate governance. As individual investors become more empowered to vote according to their values, the information deemed material may expand beyond traditional financial metrics to include a wider array of social and environmental factors. This shift underscores the dynamic nature of materiality and its critical role in shaping corporate transparency and accountability.

Comments Welcome or Contact Influencers

Sasja Beslik, Alex Thaler, J. Alan Reid, Jr., Cambria Allen Ratzlaff, Frank Partnoy, Sanford Lewis, Andrew Behar, JUST Capital, Joseph Grundfest, Matthew Nestler, PhD Rick Alexander, Tracy Stewart, CFA, Eric Weinstein, Jon Lukomnik, James Hawley, Mark Latham, Meredith Miller, Dan Ariely, Mindy Lubber, Martin Whittaker, Adam Cummings, Samson Sprouse

   

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments are closed.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes