Explainer graphic: the SEC proposes to rescind Rule 14a-8 and expand management's discretionary voting. Timeline from 1942 adoption to comments due November 20, 2026, and possible court review."

Rule 14a-8 Rescission: What We Can Say Now, What We Still Need (Part 1)

Working draft for discussion. Posted October 11, 2026. Comments to the SEC are due Friday, November 20, 2026 (File No. S7-2026-32).

The SEC has proposed to rescind Rule 14a-8, the rule that, since 1942, has required public companies to include qualifying shareholder proposals in their proxy statements. It would also let management vote uninstructed shares on proposals left off the company’s proxy card unless a shareholder checks an opt-out box. The proposal was published at 91 FR 59904 (Sept. 21, 2026) (PDF). Page citations below are to the Federal Register version.

Most of us expect the Commission to adopt something close to what it proposed. If so, the comment record matters most for what comes next: a court reviewing the final rule will look at only what commenters raised, not issues attorneys may think of when filing the lawsuit, and whether the Commission answered. This post is my attempt to set out what we can say now, what evidence we still need, and what we need to decide.

Parts 2 and 3 of this series set out thoughts on a working draft of my next comment letter. The [bracketed, highlighted notes] mark material I or others still need to gather, legal and economic choices we should talk through, and facts to verify. I’m posting it unfinished on purpose to help our collaborative efforts. Tell me where I’m wrong, borrow arguments, improve them, and send me what you know. Please write your own letter in your own words; substantially identical letters are often grouped together and aren’t considered as significant.

About this series

  • Part 1 (this post): where things stand, what we need, and how to comment.
  • Part 2: working draft letter, legal objections: the SEC’s authority, the policy rationale, alternatives (including an independent review process that the SEC can run itself), and reliance. [LINK TO PART 2]
  • Part 3: working draft letter, economic and voting objections: the one-sided cost-benefit ledger, who gets priced out, the 2020 findings, the opt-out default, and process. [LINK TO PART 3]

Where things stand

What we can say now

  • The release never mentions the one time Congress amended Section 14(a) itself: Dodd-Frank § 971 (2010), which authorizes rules requiring a company’s own proxy solicitation to include a shareholder’s director nominee.
  • The release’s own rules concede the mechanism. It accepts universal proxy, keeps Rule 14a-7, and its new Rule 14a-4(c) would require companies to describe omitted shareholder proposals.
  • The release rejected a rule deferring entirely to state law because it could increase included proposals “perhaps significantly” (91 FR 59958). That means today’s rule sometimes screens out proposals that state law allows.
  • The economic analysis puts a number on $39.6 million a year in issuer savings, but the only cost it puts a number on is $1,063 (91 FR 59952).
  • By the release’s own data, individual proponents’ proposals draw the most support (91 FR 59941), and individuals, such as John Chevedden and me, are the proponents most likely to be priced out.

What we need to gather

  • Documented outcomes: bylaw amendments, policy changes, and disclosures that followed proposals, with dates and public filings.
  • Real cost quotes for an independent solicitation on one precatory proposal at a large and a small company to be used as examples.
  • Examples of proposals with less than majority support that led to change and estimated impact.
  • Evidence on litigation avoided by right-to-cure provisions and estimated impact.

What we need to decide

  • Which alternative to rescission to lead with, and which to offer only as fallbacks?
  • Whether and how to present an independent-panel approach, such as Sarah Wilson‘s, keeping it within the SEC’s own authority.
  • How to spread arguments across many letters so every issue is in the record.
  • Whether to raise pretext and prejudgment, and how carefully.

Guidance for your own comment

This is general information, not legal advice. Please also read the Shareholder Rights Group’s advice for commenting on the proposed rescission of Rule 14a-8. (I encourage you to join) If anything here differs from that guide, follow the guide. SRG has offered to help investors prepare letters.

  • You don’t need to address everything. A focused letter that develops one or two issues with your own evidence is more useful than one that touches everything briefly.
  • Say who you are. Holdings, assets under management, beneficiaries, or your history as a proponent. Mention proposals you have pending or plan to file.
  • Use facts from your own experience. Company, year, subject and result. What changed, and when. Hours and dollars you spent, if you can support them. What you would do if the rule is rescinded.
  • Attach your evidence. Reports, filings and correspondence you rely on become part of the record a court reviews.
  • Be specific. Name the concern, cite the release page, and ask the Commission to respond.
  • Name alternatives. Say the Commission should keep the rule, and which narrower alternatives you would accept if it does not.
  • Be precise about data. Keep seasons and definitions separate. If a tracker entry of “100%” records an agreement rather than a vote, say so.

Which SEC questions each issue answers

IssueSEC questions
Authority under Section 14(a)1, 3
Narrower alternatives1, 7, 48
Reliance and negotiated outcomes2, 33, 36, 45
Costs shifted to shareholders4, 34, 35, 37, 38, 47
Cost of independent solicitation6, 37, 38, 39, 42
Opt-out default and check box14, 15, 17–21, 43, 49
Combined effect of both changes10, 39, 42, 43
State law and private ordering5, 8, 9, 46, 47
Registered funds12, 13
Technical proxy mechanics22–32

How and when to file

  • Deadline: Friday, November 20, 2026.
  • Where: [Rescission of Rule 14a-8’s Federal Regulation of Shareholder Proposals and Amendments to Rule 14a-4. Submit Public Comments. View Received Comments.], where you can upload a PDF.
  • Title: “Rescission of Rule 14a-8’s Federal Regulation of Shareholder Proposals and Amendments to Rule 14a-4 [Release No. 34-106383; File No. S7-2026-32].”
  • Address: Vanessa A. Countryman, Secretary, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, 100 F Street NE, Washington, DC 20549-1090.
  • Late and supplemental letters: When I headed rulemaking at a California agency, I often accepted comments up until a decision was made. That went beyond what the law required. Don’t count on the SEC doing the same. File by November 20.
  • Keep a copy of your filed PDF and the date it was posted.

How you can help

Send me any of the following, even partial:

  • Proposals that won less than a majority but led to change, with sources, estimated costs/savings.
  • Real quotes for independent solicitations.
  • Ideas for estimating litigation avoided by right-to-cure provisions.
  • Counsel’s views on forum, standing, and keeping a procedural review process within the SEC’s authority.
  • Improvements to any argument in this series.

Sources

Collaborate with CorpGov.net on Social Media (or Leave Comments at the bottom)

Linkedin
BlueSky
Facebook
Mastodon
Substack
X (formerly Twitter)

Rule 14a-8 Rescission: Related Posts

SEC Proposes to Rescind Rule 14a-8: Initial Comments

Sarah Wilson Offers a Better Way Than Rule 14a-8 Rescission — With Guardrails

SEC Quorum Rule: A Commission of One, Adopted Without Public Comment

Rule 14a-8: A Failed Experiment in Merit Regulation (Still)

, , , , , , , , , ,

Comments are closed.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes