Capitalisn’t, the Stigler Center podcast hosted by Bethany McLean and Luigi Zingales, recently ran an episode with Harvard Law Professor Larry Lessig titled The Case That Could End Super PACs. It is worth a listen. A pending federal appeal could change how money flows into the 2028 elections, and it has implications for those of us who have spent years pressing corporations on political spending.
Lessig’s Argument: Blame SpeechNow, Not Citizens United
Most people blame Citizens United v. FEC (2010) for super PACs. Lessig says that is wrong. Citizens United held that truly independent expenditures cannot be limited because they pose no risk of quid pro quo corruption. Super PACs came from a different case decided two months later by the D.C. Circuit, SpeechNow.org v. FEC. That court reasoned that if a committee spends independently, contributions to that committee must also be free of corruption risk.
Lessig calls that a logical error. A super PAC may never talk to a candidate, but a donor can. The donor can ask the candidate what is needed, make a deal, and then write the check to the super PAC. His example is the 2015 indictment of Senator Robert Menendez, which alleged a bribe paid as a super PAC contribution. That is the very thing the D.C. Circuit said could not happen.
Other points from the episode:
- Dependence corruption. Candidates depend on a tiny fraction of the 1% for funding. That functions like Boss Tweed controlling nominations, and it selects for politicians who will not stand up to power.
- Concentration of funders. According to Lessig, billionaires accounted for 0.3% of outside spending in 2010 and 19% in 2024.
- Transparency alone is not enough. Without other reforms, disclosure just gives us a transparently corrupt system and convinces voters they do not matter.
- Coordination goes unenforced. The Court allowed coordinated spending to be treated as a contribution, but the FEC, which currently lacks a quorum, does not police it.
- AI super PACs. Lessig fears AI companies will follow the crypto industry’s playbook, using super PACs to signal which lines Congress cannot cross.
The Case: Dinner Table Action v. Schneider
In 2024, nearly 75% of Maine voters approved a $5,000 cap on contributions to super PACs. Two super PACs sued, and a federal magistrate judge struck the law down. But she acknowledged that contributions to independent committees can create a risk of quid pro quo corruption. Maine, Lessig’s group Equal Citizens, and counsel Neal Katyal appealed.
The First Circuit heard oral argument on July 29, 2026. Then on June 30, the Supreme Court decided NRSC v. FEC, striking down limits on political party coordinated expenditures 6-3. The First Circuit asked for supplemental briefing on what that ruling means for Maine. The Campaign Legal Center argues that super PACs differ from parties because they can accept unlimited, untraceable money from shell companies and dark-money groups. The Brennan Center also filed in support of Maine.
A decision could come any day. If Maine wins, it creates a split with every circuit that has followed SpeechNow, and Supreme Court review becomes likely. Lessig hopes for a decision by July 2027, in time for the 2028 elections.
What a Win Would and Would Not Do
My own read is that Maine has a reasonable chance in the First Circuit but faces a much steeper climb at a Supreme Court that just struck down party coordination limits. Even a complete win would cap pooled money, not spending. Under Citizens United, individuals and corporations could still spend unlimited sums independently in their own names. Expect money to shift toward political parties, which NRSC just freed to coordinate with candidates, and toward direct spending by the very wealthy.
For shareholders, that shift matters. If large donors can no longer hide behind super PACs, more corporate money may move into direct independent expenditures, trade associations, and 501(c)(4) groups. Company-level disclosure and board oversight of political spending become more important, not less.
CorpGov.net Concerns
This is a topic I have followed since the day Citizens United was decided. I’ve looked at UK-style shareowner pre-approval of political contributions but don’t have much political influence, so encouraged a massive number of shareowner resolutions to accomplish the same thing. Reviewed Robert A.G. Monks book showing how passive ownership produces “drone” corporations. He called for requiring super PACs to report major donors. Wrote about Shari Dunn’s interview with Julie Goodridge of NorthStar Asset Management about shareholder proposals that align corporate political giving with stated values. Discussed that Justice Kennedy assumed shareholders could see and police corporate political speech, but the required disclosures never materialized. Many more discussions can be found on CorpGov.net on this topic.
Lessig’s critique of transparency is a useful challenge to those of us who have long pushed disclosure. Disclosure is necessary. But as Lessig points out, it does little good if officeholders remain dependent on a handful of funders. The Maine case attacks that dependence directly. Whatever the courts decide, shareholders still hold one of the few levers Justice Kennedy pointed to in 2010. We should use it. File and vote for proposals asking companies to disclose all political spending, direct and indirect, including payments to trade associations and 501(c)(4) groups. Those proposals should also ask that the spending be reviewed by the board and aligned with the company’s stated values. Then check how your mutual funds and pension plans voted on those proposals. If they voted against, ask them why.
Collaborate with CorpGov.net on Social Media (or Leave Comments at the bottom)
Linkedin
BlueSky
Facebook
Mastodon
Substack
X (formerly Twitter)
Super PACs: Related Posts
‘We the People’ Already Have a Partial Road Map to Fight Citizens United: Stocks and Mutual Funds

Comments are closed.