As I get older, I (James McRitchie) reflect on where some of my thoughts on corporate governance originated, especially as I lament not only our lack of progress but also our recent backsliding. Where did I/we go wrong? Nell Minow’s Keynote to ICGN this year prompted more such reflections and offers rays of hope.
Personal Roots Before Minow
The roots of my theories on corporate governance have vague origins. Growing up in suburban Mt. Lebanon in 1954-1965, when Pittsburgh was third in the number of US corporate headquarters, I became aware of inequality. Back then, CEOs earned about 20 times the median wage of their workers. I recall a high-ranking father. He was so disconnected from economic realities that he believed his son had purchased a diamond choker for his girlfriend with money earned from working five hours a week at a local men’s clothing store. No, my friend didn’t get the money, earning $1.60 an hour; he dealt heroin, I wanted to tell his father.
Early in college, I read The Social Construction of Reality by Peter Berger and Thomas Luckmann. Their explanation was the most straightforward I had read, detailing how knowledge, including our everyday reality, is constructed. Reality develops and is seen through the lens of externalization, objectification, and internalization, facilitated by language framing that perception. Since much of what we take for real is socially constructed, I thought the screwed up parts could also be reconstructed. I had a falling out with Berger decades later at Boston College when I learned he was largely content with our social economy.
From Carole Pateman’s Participation and Democratic Theory, I learned that meaningful participation by the masses is essential in developing individuals with political competence, autonomy, and a sense of civic responsibility. The workplace is the most formative institution for lifelong learning. Some form of industrial democracy is necessary if we want democracy to be robust in everyday life, not just in the few minutes it takes to vote in political elections.
Jaroslav Vanek’s The Participatory Economy presented me with many foundational arguments for an alternative economic model based on worker self-management, democratic participation, and decentralized planning. I began to see how society could plan an evolutionary path toward a more inclusive and human-centered (social) economy.
Paul Bernstein’s Workplace Democracy provided a comparative and empirically grounded study that explored the conditions necessary for sustainable and effective democratic management of enterprises. Drawing on 50 case studies from 15 countries, ranging from full worker control to partial participatory schemes, Bernstein identified core mechanisms and organizational dynamics that support or hinder workplace democratization. Core dimensions were the degree of control, issues controlled, and organizational level.
I briefly headed California’s efforts to develop cooperatives. That experience, as well as being one of many who tried to save Rath Packing through employee ownership, led me to conclude that the existing power structures made successfully replicating worker and consumer cooperatives like Mondragon from the ground up less likely than transforming corporations to be more democratic. Although both paths were worthy of dedication, I needed to focus on one if I was to be most helpful.
Friends had died of strange illnesses related to chemicals and neurotoxins in the environment. Along with a dying friend, I wrote legislation to address what we called “Chemical Hypersensitivity Syndrome” (those with weaker immune systems die earlier than the rest of us). We were able to get the bill passed, but the California Manufacturers’ Association and the California Medical Association requested and got a veto.
This was all long before Citizens United, but it was apparent to me that the Department of Toxic Substances Control could only regulate hazardous waste, not toxic substances. The experts on our side had significantly less financial resources and influence than the industry. Banning even lipstick containing significant amounts of lead would have to wait.
Minow and Monks
As the cover of Power & Accountability by Robert A. G. Monks and Nell Minow put it, “Corporations determine far more than any other institution the air we breathe, the quality of the water we drink, even where we live. Yet they are not accountable to anyone.”
Bob and Nell quickly became heroes of mine as I first tried to reform how my pension, CalPERS, was governed and then focused on corporate governance, filing hundreds of proposals over the decades. Looking back on it, I often wonder what we accomplished. I was hoping to visit Bob in Maine in the Fall when I will also attend a reunion of the Program on Social Economy and Social Policy at Boston College. Bob shared many of my frustrations, even though he accomplished so much. Alas, I waited too long to commiserate.
Unfortunately, Monks died near the end of April. I still have a hard time processing that fact, even though I have lost friends I was much closer to. Monks was such a giant in stature and influence that even though his body gave out, he will continue to influence many of us for years to come.
Nell Minow knows how to turn a phrase. I’ll never forget her: “Boards of directors are like subatomic particles — they behave differently when they are being observed.” When the press call and want a quotable quote, I often refer them to Nell. “All business is show business.” As the Queen of Good Corporate Governance (BusinessWeek Online 2003) and the Movie Mom, Nell knows both.
Minow’s Keynote to ICGN
Nell Minow’s Keynote to ICGN has all the elements of a great speech. She outlines the historical context of corporate governance, beginning with when she and Monks co-founded Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS). Minow goes on to note how they held corporations accountable by providing meaningful proxy voting advice. She later outlined essential reforms, such as increased voting transparency and an expanded framework for assessing risks in human capital, as well as externalities.
From Bob’s light bulb moment that got him involved in corporate governance to references to the New Yorker, to O. J. Simpson and the “Wall Street Walk,” Nell tells stories like no one else. I’m filing this post under corporate governance history so that I can easily find Nell’s speech to ICGN after the rise of Donald Trump and the death of Bob Monks.
Corporations are externalizing machines. Their prime directive is not making money; it is imposing as many costs as possible on everyone else. Minimizing this is one of the fundamental contributions of good corporate governance and that requires engaged, aware, and fearless investors…
Remember Star Wars, though, After “A New Hope” comes “The Empire Strikes Back.” Efforts to silence shareholders in the US are in all three branches of government at the federal and state levels, with Missouri and Florida Attorney General investigations, the anti-proxy advisory firm and anti-shareholder Texas laws, two Congressional hearings this spring — I testified in both — and lawsuits.
Nell Minow offers five explicit takeaways and plenty of food for thought, based on four decades of experience.

Comments are closed.