Bob Monks, his wife Millie and my wife Myra Kalani Young after breakfast in Maine

A Letter to Robert A. G. Monks

Dear Bob,

I read your final reflections—Advice to a Younger Me—not once, but several times. Intending to write a book review. I ended up writing this letter of reflection because that’s what your last book invites readers to do. Yours is not really an autobiography. It is a reckoning. And it is impossible to read your book without recognizing that your life, in ways both direct and indirect, altered the trajectory of mine.

This letter is about your book. It is also about the argument we never quite finished.
And it is about the kinship I felt with you—despite, and perhaps because of, the gulf between our origins.

The Island and the Farm

You begin with Roque Island—acquired by your ancestor Joseph Peabody around 1800. You recall asking your father what other secret places the family owned. Ownership, obligation, belonging—blurred into inheritance. That opening scene stayed with me.

When I first visited Moose Jaw and Unity, Saskatchewan, I felt something similar—not islands, but farms, cooperative banks, gas stations, grocery stores shaped by prairie socialists. My grandfather settled in Moose Jaw because when the train stopped, he recognized two draft horses he had groomed back east. He knew he would find community. My uncles owned the real estate agency he founded and a surplus WWII jeep they used to deliver life-saving drugs during blizzards. There were no servants’ quarters. No Gilded Age mansions. But there was an unmistakable sense of shared ownership and mutual reliance.

Your childhood unfolded in Lenox among Vanderbilts, Carnegies, and Rockefellers. Eight bedrooms. Seven servants, including a cook and a butler. A limousine ride to grade school, shared with Vanderbilt children.

Mine unfolded in Mt. Lebanon among executives and researchers. A three-bedroom house my friends called “the closet,” because of its small size. Your mother was the first woman in her social group to get a driver’s license. My father didn’t see the need, even though it left my mother isolated with no nearby stores or bus service. I taught her to drive once I learned myself.

Different landscapes. But both of us were shaped by proximity to power—and by early questions about how that power was used, and for whose benefit.

Privilege Without Happiness

You describe your childhood as “full of inherited privilege, external expectations, and little true happiness.” That sentence unlocks the book.

You never wrote as a man ashamed of privilege. Nor as one blind to it. “Harvard was essentially a neighborhood college. When I showed up there as a sophomore, I probably knew 400 or so people of my class of about 1,000 from the schools I had previously attended.”

You married Millicent (Milly) Sprague, descendants of Thomas Carnegie. Both of you had trust funds. You bought a house just off the Harvard campus and hired a maid. Both of you “went out for meals, almost out of necessity,” since neither of you could cook. Apparently, learning how to do so wasn’t a high priority.

My wife’s family was also once wealthy—but lost everything after the communist takeover in China. Her mother walked 1,500 miles from Kunming to Macau with a baby and a toddler, without possessions. She had to learn self-reliance.

You write as someone burdened by privilege—aware that your early offer of a law firm partnership at thirty-one owed more to your connections and rainmaking than to brilliance. When you turned it down, you chose a more direct route to deal-making, wealth accumulation, and autonomy.

Here lies the paradox that defined you: You rejected hierarchy without relinquishing its benefits. You called yourself “a traitor to your class,” yet remained fluent in its language and welcomed the access it provided.

Yet, without that vantage point, could you have done what you did? You used the tools you were given and worked so hard to hone.

Turning Points

In 1972, while campaigning in the Republican primary for the U.S. Senate in Maine, you encountered a powerful stench overnight that made your eyes tear up. You were told it was a paper mill’s nightly discharge of machine oil and solvents into the Penobscot River (washingtonpost.com).

At a meeting you chaired of the Boston Safe Deposit and Trust Company, you noticed that the bank’s portfolio included a company linked to the “industrial sludge” polluting the Penobscot. The very trust institution you oversaw was a shareholder in the polluting enterprise.

That discovery crystallized the idea that defined your career. Instead of relying solely on regulators or taxpayers to clean up pollution, shareholders themselves could use their proxy power to force companies to change. “Informed shareholders could use their proxy power to force management’s hand to clean up the industrial pollution. But none of us was doing it.” (washingtonpost.com)

A couple of my turning points came at a younger age with minor issues. In eighth grade, while studying China, our teacher asserted that it was the second-largest country by landmass. When I corrected her and provided evidence, she sent me to the vice principal’s office. He beat me and told me never to question a teacher. Power and authority could impose an arbitrary reality.

Again at university, I realized the economics being taught was based on untrue assumptions about human nature driven by greed… a misapplication of Adam Smith’s second great book. I dropped out and moved to Canada, a more humane society, and took up the sociology of knowledge.

The Dark Edge of Strategy

One line stopped me: “By taking a job that no self-respecting, ambitious human being would take…”

That was in reference to heading the Pension Welfare Benefits Administration at the Department of Labor. It was the job that positioned you to learn what you needed to launch your next project, Institutional Shareholder Services.

I admire the candor. But I struggle with the framing. “No self-respecting, ambitious human being…” What of the teacher? The plumber? The barista? The professor? Are they lacking self-respect or ambition? No. They are simply not operating inside the same gravitational field of elite opportunity.

Here is where we diverged most sharply. You often viewed your moves through the lens of elite mobility—even when rebelling against their transgressions. I have mostly looked at power from below or from the side, not from within.

But here is the truth: without your strategic calculation, there would have been no ISS. Without the ISS, fiduciary proxy voting might have remained a theory rather than an infrastructure. You institutionalized dissent.

ERISA and the Fiduciary Revolution

Your most enduring conceptual contribution was deceptively simple: Proxy votes are fiduciary assets.

ERISA’s mandate—solely in the interest of beneficiaries—meant that proxy voting was not optional. Pension managers were trustees of ownership power that had to be exercised to benefit those beneficiaries. That insight altered the field and maybe the economy.

Founding ISS in 1985 operationalized that principle. Nell Minow joined in 1986. Public pensions like CalPERS became early customers. That same year, I ran for the CalPERS Board—probably the only candidate who made proxy voting central to a campaign. The blurb on the book cover of Power & Accountability, which you wrote with Nell, is repeated on every page of CorpGov.net:

Corporations determine far more than any other institution the air we breathe, the quality of the water we drink, even where we live. Yet they are not accountable to anyone

That wasn’t a new idea to me. I worked for Cal/EPA to enforce corporate accountability. But that book cover reorganized my thinking. I wasn’t alone in thinking about the potential for corporate owners to take greater responsibility for corporate behavior.

Aside from a CalPERS pension, I was also building small portfolios in 401(k) and 457 plans. The funds offered to state employees voted against everything we worked for. Our funds voted against human rights, worker rights, environmental protections, and protections for children.

We first met at a conference in Hong Kong in 1998. In my speech, I built on your thesis that fulfilling fiduciary duties could materially improve corporate performance while better aligning companies’ values with those of their owners. I also noted that those fiduciary duties had been weakly enforced. I was a little hurt when you declined to be photographed with me. Was I more of a firebrand than you were comfortable being seen with? We never had that conversation.

Our paths converged there—though at different altitudes.

Harvard: Betrayal and Obsession

Your lifelong fixation on Harvard fascinates me. You donated your house; they sold it. You urged them to lead on responsible ownership; they declined. You kept returning, hoping to convert the elite institution you knew best.

I graduated from a state college because tuition was fifty dollars a semester.

You believed elite endowments could lead the reforms. I focused on mobilizing dispersed beneficial and retail owners. Your strategy was top-down enlightenment. Mine has been mobilizing from the middle-out.

Yet, decades later, you flew me out to speak to “Divest Harvard.” Perhaps I could help facilitate your intergenerational conversation, though I wasn’t much closer to the students’ age than you were. We both believed persuasion still mattered. We disagreed on leverage. We agreed on the necessity.

Sears, Exxon, and the Hotel Room Non-Performing Assets, the Sears Board

Your campaign for a single seat on the Sears board remains legendary. $750,000 of your own money. A $23 million corporate defense. Thirty employees were assigned to defeat you. The “Non-Performing Assets” ad with silhouettes of the Sears board.

You recount threats in a hotel room, imagining a horse’s head on your pillow. Fury from entrenched directors. Being called a “professional troublemaker.”

When I read that, I thought of an attorney representing Waste Management, telling me they would own my house after court costs. You spent $750,000, lost, and built a reputation. I spent $50, won, and built obscurity. Different scale. Same asymmetry.

Corporations will spend vastly more to silence dissent than dissenters can muster to speak. Across radically different class origins, we encountered the same institutional reflex: protect managerial sovereignty at any cost.

Where We Diverged

You believed reform could emerge through enlightened elites rediscovering stewardship. “Let us unite in our commitment to restore the values of accountability, integrity, and self-governance…”

I was never as sanguine about returning to a golden age. My interest in governance began in the 1950s and 1960s when I saw executives earning 30 times more than workers, and minorities, including Mohamad Ali, were excluded from buying homes in our town under redlining.

When reading your drafts, I often tried to reorient your perspective from top-down to bottom-up or middle-out. You saw governance reform as enlightenment. I saw it as a redistribution of power.

I came to share your focus on shareholder primacy—not because it is morally sufficient, but because it is legally actionable. Employees could be empowered within the current framework if they held stock in proportion to their contributions and voted in their own interests.

Courts expanded corporate speech rights. Dark money proliferated. Index funds rationally free rode. Texas and Florida attacked fiduciary ESG considerations.

You trusted enlightenment, reminding me of Edward R. Murrow’s admonition to McCarthy, “Have you no shame?” I trust enforceable design—reciprocal disclosure, cure provisions, structural rights with remedies embedded in bylaws.

But we are arguing inside the same frame.

You asked whether corporations could be made accountable to their owners.
I ask whether capitalism and democracy remain legitimate if workers have no meaningful voice.

The Kinship

Why did I feel kinship with you?

Not because our class backgrounds aligned. They did not.
Not because our strategies matched. They did not.

But because neither of us could accept managerial sovereignty as natural.

You wrestled with legitimacy from inside the mansion. I wrestled with it just outside the gates.

You were called a traitor to your class. I have been called naïve, obsessive, and disruptive.

We both refused polite complicity. Perhaps most importantly, neither of us crossed into nihilism. Even as evidence mounted that capture was deep, we continued writing as if legitimacy mattered.

The Unfinished Argument

Your final book is uneven. It carries blind spots. It occasionally reveals the gravitational pull of elite validation you never fully escaped. But it is honest.

You leveraged privilege to challenge privilege. You institutionalized dissent. You made proxy voting a moral act. You believed informed and motivated owners could reclaim stewardship.

I believe ownership must be structurally empowered to do so. These are not opposing views. They are iterations across time.

Closing

Bob, your life altered mine. Power and Accountability, along with your other books, especially those with Nell, and our conversations, reorganized my thinking. Your articulation of fiduciary duty gave CorpGov.net focus. Your willingness to confront boards at scale validated my hundreds of smaller battles.

You began with Roque Island—inheritance, belonging, obligation. You ended with stewardship—accountability, legitimacy, democracy.

You once asked whether corporations could be made accountable to their owners. I am still asking whether democracy can survive if corporations are not themselves more democratic.

You were a traitor to your class. My concerns have always been to reduce class power differentials.

I have regrets, Bob, but they aren’t about our disagreements. They’re about my reluctance to reach out. I told myself I was respecting your time, keeping a professional distance, or waiting until I had something worth saying. Mostly, I assumed there would always be another chance. I was wrong.

I wish I had said thank you while you could still answer, but time isn’t a renewable asset.

Collaborate with CorpGov.net on Social Media (or Leave a Reply at the bottom)

Linkedin
BlueSky
Facebook
Mastodon
Substack
X (formerly Twitter)

Related Posts

In Memory of Robert A. G. Monks

Nell Minow and Other Major Influences

Review Essay: Citizens DisUnited

Fiduciary Duty to Announce Votes (Part 2): Historical Background

Nell Minow: Advice for Shareholders

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments are closed.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes