Democratizing investing is desperately needed in the United States. Stock market wealth in the United States is highly concentrated among the wealthiest households. The top 1% of Americans own approximately 31% of all U.S. equities, while the top 10% collectively control 87%. The top 50% of households hold around 97.5% of stock market wealth, leaving the bottom half with just 2-3%. Stock ownership is heavily skewed toward affluent families. Larry Fink’s annual letter solution is to open up more investment vehicles to grow BlackRock’s clientele and “make their money grow—as much as possible, as fast as possible.” Below, I argue that although more investment options could be good, it would be even better for BlackRock to rethink its fiduciary standards to help ensure an economy that works for all. That would be a better definition of democratizing investing.
Democratizing Investing: Choice and Returns Versus Agency and Voice
BlacKRock confuses product choice and returns with agency and voice. I applaud Larry Fink for making BlackRock more inclusive. However, democratizing investing must extend beyond his simple goal of broadening investment choices. That’s too much like saying we can save the world by shopping more.
Democratizing Investing as Agency and Voice
- Citizens, shareholders, or beneficial owners act as principals who delegate authority to elected officials, boards of directors, or fund managers through competitive elections or other choice mechanisms, ensuring policy and service accountability.
- Voice enables individuals to communicate their preferences and influence policymaking through voting, advocacy, or protest.
- Inclusive systems that provide space for diverse voices enhance satisfaction with democracy, intermediaries like BlackRock, and companies by ensuring representation beyond mere electoral outcomes.
Democratizing Investing as Consumer and Investor Choice
- Consumer sovereignty, where individuals “vote” through economic choices in the marketplace. Neoliberals argue that consumer choice mirrors democratic participation by enabling individuals to influence production and policy indirectly.
- They see investor participation as a form of political engagement that shapes societal priorities.
- The idea is that free markets inherently support democratic governance by expanding individual freedoms and choices in consumer decisions and in the vehicles they choose to invest in or through.
However, markets do not guarantee political equality or accountability, since economic power can overshadow political agency. Democracy depends on a more equitable distribution of wealth and the ability of citizens and investors to influence the election and decision-making of their representatives.
Democratizing Investing: Fiduciary Duty
The concept of fiduciary duty can be traced back to Roman law, rooted in republican ideals. Roman fiduciary relationships aimed to empower individuals while protecting them from domination or arbitrary control by others. This framework emphasized trust and agency, allowing principals to delegate responsibilities while safeguarding their autonomy. Over time, fiduciary principles expanded to establish specific duties for fund trustees, emphasizing loyalty and prudence. Later, the Prudent Man and Investor rules reflected evolving investment practices requiring fiduciaries to consider risk-return trade-offs and diversification.
Until recently, social, environmental, and economic risks were considered externalities, which were too uncertain to consider. Traditional fiduciary duty frameworks haven’t effectively addressed these complex, interrelated risks. However, since these issues now pose systemic risks of the type discussed by The Shareholder Commons, fiduciaries should adopt the precautionary principle of “do no harm.” This principle emphasizes putting beneficiaries’ interests first and being careful not to cause harm through investment decisions.
Fiduciaries must also consider beneficiaries’ views on risk, even helping them better understand those risks. Ignoring these perspectives could undermine long-term support for the financial system itself. Although written over a decade ago, Reclaiming Fiduciary Duty Balance by James Hawley, Keith Johnson, and Ed Waitzer remains a timely read. PRI’s Fiduciary Duty in the 21st Century is a great read on why ESG is now financially material and must be incorporated into investment analysis and decision-making processes, consistent with investment time horizons. Please alert me to additional discussions on fiduciary duty that take a broad approach.
Democratizing Investing: Advice to BlackRock and Other Funds
Fink sees BlackRock’s fiduciary duty as something close to “make their money grow—as much as possible, as fast as possible.” However, as discussed, fiduciary duty does not always require maximizing returns. Instead, it requires acting in the beneficiary’s best interests, even if those wishes prioritize a salubrious environment or democracy over financial returns.
Broadening investment opportunities is good, but Fink should prioritize giving investors more agency and voice. BlackRock votes its funds to prioritize each company’s return, instead of its various portfolios of companies as a whole for each portfolio. BlackRock does not consider externalities. Two options should be added to BlackRock’s voting choices:
- Vote to reduce externalities, such as those discussed by The Shareholder Commons. while increasing the portfolio value;

- Vote by aggregating each beneficiary’s best interests through individualized, proxy voting policies like Iconikapp.com.
Thanks to Iain Withers and Ross Kerber for their article, BlackRock’s Fink warns of protectionism amid private market push. Their reporting prompted me to write the above post.

Comments are closed.