Business Roundtable Proxy Reform Response ICCR & SRG

Business Roundtable Proxy “Reform” Agenda Threatens

The Business Roundtable Proxy “Reform” Agenda was recently released in a position paper entitled “The Need for Bold Proxy Process Reforms.” Far from encouraging healthy corporate governance, their agenda presents a grave threat to shareholder rights, public accountability, and efforts to address environmental and social challenges through the corporate ballot. This is yet another plan by the CEOs of America’s largest public companies to grab power away from shareholders and the public. As Lynn Parramore notes, They Looted Companies — Now They’re Looting the Government. As Sarah C. Haan points out, Donald Trump’s Authoritarian Playbook Is Based on Failures of US Corporate Democracy, not Foreign Dictators. We cannot live in a democracy if our most important institutions, corporations, are run as authoritarian regimes.

Among their most alarming proposals:

  • Stripping shareholders of the right to file proposals on environmental, social, or political issues—precisely the concerns that are increasingly material to long-term corporate value and public well-being.
  • Imposing sky-high ownership thresholds that would effectively exclude all but the largest asset managers from submitting proposals—silencing the voices of smaller institutional investors, faith-based groups, and individual shareholders.
  • Banning the resubmission of proposals that fail to garner majority support within three years—even if they receive significant minority support or address emerging risks that deserve sustained attention.

Taken together, these so-called “reforms” would lock out nearly all stakeholders from influencing corporate behavior—leaving unaccountable boards and executives insulated from concerns about climate risk, worker rights, political spending, and other matters of public interest.

ICCR and the Shareholder Rights Group sent a joint letter (below) to the Business Roundtable’s leadership, with a copy to SEC Chair Paul Atkins, challenging these proposals and requesting an open dialogue. We believe the proxy process must remain accessible, inclusive, and responsive—not restructured to serve only the largest financial players. The largest pools of money, like BlackRock, Vanguard, and State Street, compete primarily based on low cost.  These funds have never filed a shareholder proposal. That task has always been left to those driven to ensure companies operate responsibly for the long term.

Other powerful lobbying groups, such as the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the National Association of Manufacturers, are expected to join this effort to restrict shareholder democracy.  Stayed tuned.

Business Roundtable Proxy “Reform”: Response by ICCR and SRC

Joshua Bolton, CEO                                                                                                                                   May 6, 2025 Elizabeth Dougherty, COO

Business Roundtable

Dear Mr. Bolton and Ms. Dougherty,

We write on behalf of the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility (ICCR) and the Shareholder Rights Group (SRG) in response to the Business Roundtable’s April 2025 white paper, “The Need for Bold Proxy Process Reforms”.

ICCR  is  a coalition of over  300  institutional investors representing  US$4  trillion in assets under management who engage their portfolio companies to help mitigate environmental and social risks. SRG is an association of investors formed to defend shareholders’ right to engage with public companies on governance, corporate accountability, and long-term value creation.

As representatives of shareholders who regularly engage with their portfolio companies on issues of material long-term risk via the proxy process, we offer different perspectives for your consideration. Importantly, we wish to extend an invitation for a series of dialogues about this topic in the hopes of bridging the divide between our views and fostering greater understanding that will benefit all stakeholders.

The proxy process has over 70 years of history and is regularly used by a diverse set of investors with trillions of dollars of AUM to raise issues with companies that have proven time and again to have a clear and demonstrable impact on long-term shareholder value. Evidence of this positive impact is outlined in our recent paper, Shareholder Proposals: An Essential Investor Right, published by our two organizations in conjunction with US SIF. Our paper catalogues the role of proxy proposals in opening communication with corporate boards and management about ways to mitigate what informed investors view as material and long-term risks, including ways to build and protect shareholder value.

While it is not unusual for business leaders and investors to disagree about what constitutes long-term business risk, the healthy debate generated by shareholder proposals affirms the rights of proponents as part-owners to introduce new ideas and perspectives, encourages corporate transparency and disclosure, discourages board and management insularity, and,  importantly,  gives all shareholders a voice in corporate decision-making through their vote at the annual meeting.  Shareholder proposals are precatory, and as such, companies are under no obligation to adopt them. However, proposals are an articulation of interest by an informed and interested stakeholder who provides the very capital that allows for the business to exist and, for this reason, should never be easily dismissed. Any company’s effort to restrict or silence that voice is an attempt to deny critical corporate stakeholders a fundamental right.

The BRT’s recommended reforms to the proxy process appear intended to do just that through a variety of measures, including but not limited to:

  • Recommending that Congress pass a law denying shareholders the right to file proposals relating to environmental, social, and political issues for the corporate proxy statement.
  • Establishing unreasonably high stockholding thresholds that would preclude all but the largest asset managers from utilizing the process.
  • Preventing the re-filing of any proposals that don’t achieve over 50% support by the third year of filing.

Other recommendations include eliminating the ability of shareholders to collaborate to develop effective proposals, preventing proponents from identifying misleading information in corporate opposition statements before their publication, blocking small shareholders from filing exempt solicitations to further communicate with fellow shareholders, and barring shareholders from utilizing the universal proxy to pay for their own proxy solicitations.

Collectively, these recommendations appear designed to close off communication with all but the largest asset managers that, generally, don’t utilize the proxy process, conduct limited engagements given their vast holdings, and have a narrower definition of long-term risk than investors guided by ESG metrics. While this approach may make it easier for companies to conduct their business unimpeded in the short term, it will result in board/management insularity that will weaken corporate governance in the long term.

The  BRT’s arguments against a more democratic proxy process are based on a narrow,  selectively constructed survey of  35  member companies and further weighted toward a subset of the seven companies most aggressively opposed to proxy proposals. As a result, a not insignificant amount of text is devoted to advancing the myth that the hundreds of proponents in any given proxy season are a monolithic group of small,  politically motivated stakeholders unconcerned with shareholder  value. Corporations know that shareholder proponents run the gamut from individual investors and smaller religious and mission-aligned investors to large global fiduciary funds, state, city, and labor pensions, and everything in between. Their motives for raising specific environmental, social, and governance risks through proposals may vary, but they are universally concerned with how those risks impact society and the environment and the consequences they may have for short and long-term financial performance. Motives aside, as providers of capital, they all have the same right to a once-a-year audience with their portfolio companies and fellow shareholders at the annual stockholder meeting. We also note that investors like religious congregations and others with civil society connections may have smaller holdings, but they often represent organizations with global footprints that can help make companies aware of harmful impacts from their operations well before they manifest as financial and legal risks. This “intel” has always been welcomed and valued by the companies our members engage with, as it serves as an early warning system, and we have numerous examples of their testimonials to that fact.

We do acknowledge that certain proposal topics, such as those invoking the climate crisis and corporate diversity and inclusion programs, have been seized upon by parties intent on making them hyper-politicized culture war issues.  While unfortunate,  the current political rhetoric does not negate the relevance of these environmental and social factors as material and systemic financial risks to companies across all sectors of the market. They remain closely linked to long-term shareholder value and, for that reason, are legitimate issues investors should be permitted to raise through proposals if they believe they aren’t being adequately addressed by the board and management.  Most companies recognize this and report annually to shareholders on their efforts on these and other critical sustainability issues. There are many sustainability champions at Fortune 500 companies.

We also want to address the complaint from some survey respondents that the cost to oppose shareholder proposals is excessive. We see this as easily remedied should companies simply not challenge proposals at the SEC and allow shareholders to vote on them on their merits at annual meetings. We believe this approach is ultimately more democratic and would save both proponents and companies a not inconsiderable amount of time and money.

As we have in the past, we wish to remind you that shareholder proposals are not the preferred method of engagement by our members; dialogues are. Investors have enjoyed fruitful and regular discussions with their portfolio companies, many of which are BRT members, that have resulted in strengthened policies and practices that obviate the need to file shareholder proposals. However, when they do file proposals, companies have been receptive to discussing them because they acknowledge the financial materiality of the risks the proponents raise and see the value in efforts to mitigate them. Indeed, since 2020, shareholder proposals have prompted over 650 agreements on a range of issues related to environmental and social impacts and governance questions, reducing risk for both companies and their investors. We view this as significant progress worth celebrating.

To summarize, the proxy process is not broken or in need of “bold reform.” Its enduring strength lies in its capacity to evolve alongside market realities and investor priorities. The BRT’s recommendations would turn back the clock and insulate corporate management and boards, exposing companies and investors to increased risk during a highly volatile economic moment.

Ultimately, this is the purview of the Federal Agency designated to protect investor rights, the Securities and Exchange Commission, whose new Chairman, Paul Atkins, we copy here. We reiterate our invitation to dialogue about these issues and feel confident that through conversation, we will achieve an improved understanding of the value of the proxy process that will benefit all stakeholders.

Sincerely,

Josh   Zinner

CEO, Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility (ICCR)

Sanford Lewis

Director, Shareholder Rights Group (SRG)

CC:  Paul Atkins, SEC  and Business Roundtable

Collaborate With CorpGov.net on Social Media

Linkedin

BlueSky

Facebook

Mastodon

Substack

Business Roundtable Proxy “Reform”: Related Posts

The Giant Shadow of Corporate Gadflies

BRT’s Stakeholder Capitalism

Shareholder-Driven Stakeholderism

ICCR Letter to BRT on ESG Resolutions

Shareholders v Stakeholders

My Letter to Business Roundtable on Shareholder Resolutions

Investor Letter to BRT (Business Roundtable)

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments are closed.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes