Controlled Companies Underperform

Controlled Companies Underperform

Controlled companies underperform, on average. Yes, that’s the conclusion of recent research by MSCI, which shows that widely held companies (those without a controlling shareholder) have outperformed controlled companies on both five- and ten-year total shareholder return (TSR) measures, even after accounting for company size, sector, and market development. The analysis is based on a multivariate regression involving nearly 2,000 companies in the MSCI ACWI Index from 2015 to 2025. You may want to redirect to more democratic companies.

Controlled Companies Underperform: Key MSCI Findings

  • Controlled firms (where a single entity holds more than 30% of voting power) underperformed both widely held companies and firms with a principal shareholder.
  • On average, widely held companies outperformed controlled companies by 10.3% over a 5-year period and by 14.9% over a 10-year period; both results were statistically significant.
  • The number of controlled companies has increased (now accounting for over 36% of the index by count), but despite their growing presence, widely held firms have consistently delivered superior shareholder returns.

    Some Commonly Held Controlled Companies

    Some Commonly Held Controlled Companies

Implications

  • Investors may benefit from considering ownership structure when analyzing long-term equity opportunities.
  • Despite the prevalence of controlled companies, widely held companies have created greater shareholder value over time.
  • Investors may want to consider redirecting some of their current investments away from controlled companies. The list was generated by me, not MSCI.

Controlled Companies Underperform: Methodology

MSCI’s analysis covered 1,906 companies that were continuous constituents of the MSCI ACWI Index between 2015 and 2025. This approach ensured a consistent sample for comparison over time, while minimizing the impact of index turnover (company additions or removals) on the total-shareholder-return regression results and reducing the influence of outliers. MSCI ESG Research’s three-dimensional ownership framework classifies companies into three categories under the “level of control” dimension, based on the largest owner’s voting power: (i) Controlled: Largest shareholder, or group, holds 30% or more; (ii) principal: Largest shareholder, or group, holds between 10% and 30%; and (iii) widely held: No shareholder, or group, holds more than 10%.

Collaborate with CorpGov.net on Social Media (or Leave a Reply at the bottom)

Linkedin
BlueSky
Facebook
Mastodon
Substack
X (formerly Twitter)

Controlled Companies Underperform: Related Posts

Controlled Companies Carry Negatives

Controlled Companies Underperform, Overpay

Six New Rules of Business With Judy Samuelson

Recent Research in Corporate Governance: Part 3

#ICGN16: 4, Silicon Valley Exceptionalism

Video Friday: Rise of Controlled Corporations

, , , , , , ,

Comments are closed.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes