Values Primacy & Total Governance Through Activism

Values‑Primacy & Total Governance Through Activism

Values-Primacy & Total Governance Through Activism, by Carliss Chatman and Sergio Gramitto Ricci, argues that everyday stakeholder actions—walkouts, boycotts, consumer backlash, viral campaigns, and proxy voting—function as a real, if often unacknowledged, system of corporate governance. When individuals coordinate across their multiple social roles (worker, consumer, investor, community member), they shape corporate identity more durably than any one-off reputational shock.

Values‑Primacy & Total Governance: Disclosure

This post is not a review but a reflection on how the paper helps illuminate a problem I have worked on for decades. My frame is rooted in Berger and Luckmann’s The Social Construction of Reality, which I read as a young man and later critiqued directly with Berger when I was a student of his at Boston College. Berger’s sociological model brilliantly captured how family, religion, and school shape our taken-for-granted reality as children. But as I argued then and in a 1979 student paper, Reconstructing Social Reality, Berger’s entire corpus of work underplays the continuing formative and coercive power of the modern corporation.

Corporations have become our dominant institution. Yet unlike more democratic governments, which employ 13% of Americans, corporations employ roughly 70% and remain largely autocratic. My guess is that corporate leadership is becoming more authoritarian, even as shareholders (represented by intermediaries they have little control over) have gained more influence. The result is widespread anomie: the hollowing out of agency, meaning, and moral coherence in daily work and political life. The two are conjoined, as noted by Carole Pateman.

Berger placed his hope in families and voluntary organizations as mediating structures in addressing the homeless mind and coercive state power. I was (and remain) more concerned about corporate power. That divergence led both of us out of Boston College—he to Boston University, and I into work on employee ownership and later leading California’s Cooperative Development Program. But the underlying question has persisted for me: How can individuals, fragmented into multiple and often alienated roles, reclaim enough agency to reshape the corporate institutions that shape them?

The new paper by Carliss N. Chatman and Sergio Alberto Gramitto Ricci provides some of the clearest explorations in this direction that I have seen.

Values‑Primacy & Total Governance: Activism Is Governance

The authors’ central move is deceptively simple: they reconceptualize “activism” as a form of governance machinery. Boycotts, walkouts, shareholder proposals, online campaigns—these are not noise surrounding corporate decision-making; they are decision-making pressures. In the same way, I argued in 1979 that the social reality of groups can be consciously reconstructed by participants challenging institutionalized meanings; the authors argue that stakeholders already reconstruct corporate reality whenever their values align across roles.

They call this architecture Total Governance, and its normative model values-primacy governance. The idea is that shared values—racial dignity, product safety, fair labor conditions, climate stability—become superordinate goals that crosscut roles. When embedded in corporate structures, these values become “non-reversible,” surviving political cycles, CEO transitions, and the cultural whiplash of the moment.

The paper then maps the governance design problem: current institutional arrangements—especially retirement fund intermediation—block these cross-role pressures from being expressed inside the firm. Total Governance discusses how to unblock those chokepoints and redesign them to enable less reversible, values‑anchored influence.

Values‑Primacy & Total Governance: Shareholder Advocates

1. Treat stakeholder activism as governance, not PR noise

Shareholder advocates should use the article’s framing as the new baseline: directors and asset managers cannot treat coordinated stakeholder actions as reputational irritants. They are governance signals. The case studies (Target, Levi’s, Apple, Meta, Tesla) show that when values are not structurally embedded—through board mandates, charters, advisory councils, and disclosure systems—corporations oscillate wildly, inviting legal, reputational, and systemic risk.

2. Frame proposals as fixing “reversibility by design”

Most corporate social commitments collapse because they were never embedded in governance architecture. Use the authors’ language: argue that firms have structural design flaws that make values commitments reversible.

3. Build cross-role accountability

Proposals should explicitly cultivate structures that connect stakeholder roles—worker, consumer, investor, and citizen—around superordinate goals such as safety, DEI, and climate stability.

This directly echoes my longstanding critique that institutions shape social reality by limiting which values can be publicly expressed or implemented.

Values‑Primacy & Total Governance:  Pass‑through Voting

One of the paper’s most timely extensions is into pass-through or delegated-choice voting for retirement assets. Individuals increasingly see that their 401(k)s are voting against their interests as citizens, workers, and consumers. Meanwhile, politicized pressure campaigns—Texas against BlackRock being the clearest example—push funds to disclaim any social or environmental judgment.

Pass-through voting is a governance reform that aligns neatly with Total Governance:

  • Participants already discipline firms as workers and consumers, enabling them to influence voting and internalize that influence.

  • Standing, transparent, participant-co-designed voting policies (instead of one-off polling) prevent reversibility under political threat.

  • Plan fiduciaries should recognize that cross-role values are already shaping the corporate environment. Integrating them into voting is not political activism but fiduciary realism. I prefer that course to Judge Laster assigning directors a fiduciary duty to shares, rather than to beneficial owners.

Through active engagement, we will reconstruct institutional norms that, in turn, will shape us and our future.

Values‑Primacy & Total Governance: Concrete Levers

  • Proposals asking asset managers and plan sponsors to disclose how participant preferences translate into votes.

  • Demands that default index options include at least one “values-primacy” or “stakeholder-alignment” voting policy.

  • Advocacy for advisory councils, participatory disclosure, and digital cross-role platforms—mirroring the formal infrastructures Total Governance requires.

Values‑Primacy & Total Governance: Unifying Multiple Roles

The paper points toward, and sometimes names, emerging infrastructures that already connect individuals across roles, while also emphasizing how incomplete and fragmented they remain.

  • Social‑media‑driven “murmurations” where people coordinate boycotts, brand pressure, and public narrative (e.g., over product safety, DEI rollbacks, platform harms) while also sometimes aligning investor and worker actions.
  • The Center for Retail Investors & Corporate Inclusion and similar projects that explicitly seek to organize retail investors around inclusion and equity often do so by connecting their roles as workers, consumers, and community members.
  • Worker‑consumer coalitions and community campaigns around particular firms (e.g., around safety, labor conditions, or content governance), which the article treats as early examples of cross‑role Total Governance, pressuring firms from multiple sides simultaneously, even when they lack formal institutionalization.

New social realities emerge through collective reinterpretation and joint action, even in the face of dominant institutional frames. Together, we can reconstruct social realities.

Conclusion

Shareholder advocates should be aware of these emerging infrastructures and join in expanding concepts such as fiduciary duty to consider beneficial owners in their multiple roles as investors, workers, consumers, citizens, and family members.

Building values-primacy governance requires institutionalizing stakeholder values so they become durable features of corporate decision-making rather than reversible rhetoric. This model demands new governance infrastructures—such as stakeholder advisory councils, participatory disclosure systems, and digital platforms for cross-role coordination—that allow individuals to act simultaneously as workers, consumers, investors, and citizens.

Directors retain strategic authority, but their legitimacy depends on systematically integrating these shared values into corporate strategy. Values-primacy governance thus transforms stakeholder engagement from episodic pressure into an ongoing civic dialogue that stabilizes corporate identity across political and market cycles, anchoring legitimacy in broad public participation rather than short-term shareholder primacy.

Corporations shape our social reality. Values-primacy governance offers a draft blueprint for reconstructing that reality. Instead of corporations imposing reality, it can be co-created by the people it affects.

Collaborate with CorpGov.net on Social Media (or Leave a Reply at the bottom)

Linkedin
BlueSky
Facebook
Mastodon
Substack
X (formerly Twitter)

Values‑Primacy & Total Governance: Related Posts

Reclaiming Fiduciary Duty

More Funds, More Choices, Less Control

The Proxy Voting Choice Revolution: Quick Thoughts

Controlled Companies Underperform

Nell Minow and Other Major Influences

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments are closed.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes