Governance Structures Matter: Employees Need a Voice at the Table to Raise Productivity and Address Wealth Inequality

Governance Structures Missing in Whittaker’s Vision

In his recent essay, Capitalism at Its Best: America’s Next 250 Years Starts Now, Martin Whittaker, CEO of JUST Capital, offers a thoughtful, historically grounded, and forward-looking call for stakeholder capitalism. He rightly highlights the fraying social contract at the heart of American economic life, identifies the practical aspirations of working people—security, dignity, purpose—and underscores that the private sector must play a leading role in meeting those aspirations.

Whittaker deserves credit for resisting ideological extremes and calling for an adaptive, empirical, and moral form of capitalism grounded in shared prosperity. Yet while the essay articulates what people want from capitalism and why reform is necessary, it stops short of confronting how those outcomes will be institutionally achieved—especially within the governance structures of corporations themselves.

If stakeholder capitalism is to deliver more than inspirational language or incremental reforms, it must address a core question: Who gets to decide? In other words, if corporations are going to respond to the needs of workers, customers, and communities, those stakeholders must have a formal voice and influence in the decision-making structures that govern firms.

Otherwise, even the best stakeholder intentions risk becoming what economist Luigi Zingales has called “enlightened autocracy”—well-meaning but unaccountable.

A Voice at the Table: In Song (Listen to all the songs in our Growing Catalog)

Governance Structures: Corporations as Reality-Makers

Whittaker rightly notes that capitalism has evolved over time, shaped by institutions, people, and technology. But he leaves underdeveloped the idea—central to democratic and organizational theory—that corporations themselves are reality-making institutions. Like governments, schools, and families, they determine the conditions under which individuals live, learn, work, and thrive. They shape time (through schedules), access (through wages and benefits), knowledge (through surveillance or learning systems), identity (through hierarchy, status, and roles), and our very conceptions of reality.

Given this power, the absence of a formal voice for workers in most corporate decision-making becomes both a moral problem and a governance failure. If people spend a third of their lives in organizations that operate as authoritarian hierarchies, then social trust, psychological well-being, and innovation all suffer.

In short: if we want capitalism to evolve into a more inclusive system, it is not enough to improve outcomes—we must also democratize the process by which those outcomes are generated. We must democratize corporate governance. 

Governance Structures: The Empirical Evidence

Whittaker emphasizes that companies that invest in their workers perform better. JUST Capital’s own indices—the JUST 100 and JUST 500—show that companies treating employees well outperform their benchmarks. These findings are central to understanding where we need to head as a society..

Yet, the metrics used—wages, benefits, training—measure how companies treat employees as beneficiaries, not whether they recognize employees as co-governors or even decision-influencers.

What if stakeholder capitalism went one step further? What if we recognized that employees are not just human capital to be invested in, but epistemic assets—knowledge holders who can shape better strategies?

Evidence supports this claim. The National Center for Employee Ownership (NCEO) finds that companies with employee stock ownership plans (ESOPs) grow 2–3% faster and are more resilient in downturns. But critically, the greatest performance gains come when ownership is paired with participation in decision-making—through councils, committees, or board representation.

The MIT Task Force on Work of the Future reports that the vast majority of employees say they have ideas to improve their organizations, but lack meaningful channels to express them. This “voice gap” is a form of internal market failure: corporations are forgoing value by not listening to those closest to operations.

A virtual plethora of benefits would result, according to research described in books such as The Citizen’s Share: Reducing Inequality in the 21st Century, and in research conducted at the Institute for the Study of Employee Ownership and Profit Sharing, and the University Consortium on Employee Share Ownership.

In an era of complex, distributed problems—from AI integration to climate adaptation—centralized decision-making without structured feedback is epistemically brittle. Voice, it turns out, is not just a fairness principle—it’s a productivity strategy.

Governance Structures vs the Enlightened CEO Model

Whittaker’s framework relies heavily on corporate leadership—CEOs, directors, and asset managers—to carry the burden of stakeholder reform. He envisions better capitalism as a product of enlightened leadership equipped with better tools, data, and analytics.

This approach reflects the CEO statesman model that has gained prominence in the ESG era. And while many executives are indeed rising to meet social expectations, the model has real limits.

First, it lacks durability. Leadership changes, incentives shift, and priorities evolve. If stakeholder governance depends on personality or elite voluntarism, it cannot be relied upon for structural change.

Second, it lacks accountability. As legal scholars such as Elizabeth Pollman and Leo Strine have noted, CEOs are not elected by workers, customers, or communities. Without formal mechanisms of accountability—such as employee board observers, participatory budgeting, or stakeholder audit committees—claims to represent stakeholder interests are unfalsifiable.

Finally, the model lacks scalability. As Whittaker notes, small and mid-sized firms are often where stakeholder commitment is strongest—but also where institutional capacity and visibility are lowest. Without legal frameworks, investor pressure, or governance innovations, these firms may struggle to maintain their commitments.

Governance Structures: The Catalyst

If stakeholder capitalism is to move from intent to implementation, we need a concrete governance agenda—one that includes, but goes beyond, environmental disclosures or human capital metrics.

Here are several practical steps, grounded in existing law and research:

1. Employee/Stakeholder Voices on Boards

Many EU countries require worker representation on boards. In the U.S., I recommend expanding the standard Proxy Access terms to lift limits on the number of participants. Employee owners should be able to combine their shares to meet the 3% threshold for the 3-year period. To be elected, director nominees must receive a majority of the vote, so employee interests and outside shareholder interests must be reconciled. Many responsible funds would be delighted to partner with employees in selecting and electing directors, prioritizing employee interests, DEI, a healthy environment, and a holistic approach to governance and innovation. Such positions can offer operational insight and legitimacy without altering fiduciary structures.

2. SEC Disclosure Rules

As part of human capital reporting, the SEC should require disclosures not only of wages and benefits but also of stock-based incentives awarded to employees and of programs that promote employee engagement in governance, such as employee advisory councils, inclusion in strategic planning, or participation in risk assessments. We should aim to expand the range of issues over which employees exercise influence, as well as the level or domain of participation. 

3. Shareholder Proposals

Under SEC Rule 14a-8, shareholders can submit proposals regarding corporate governance. Proposals requesting transparency about worker voice mechanisms—if framed as governance rather than HR—are more likely to survive no-action requests. Employee owners ought to always be able to vote their shares and to exercise the right to file shareholder proposals. 

4. Union Negotiations and Worker Organizing

Unions and worker centers can push beyond wages and working conditions to bargain for governance participation rights—especially in industries where worker input is critical to safety, innovation, or quality.

Conclusion: Voice Is the Bridge Between Values and Structures

Martin Whittaker’s essay provides an important reminder that American capitalism is dynamic rather than static. It has evolved before and must evolve again. But evolution requires an institutional framework, not just values. Stakeholder capitalism cannot rely solely on the good faith of leaders or the persuasive power of data.

The missing piece in Whittaker’s otherwise compelling framework is formal stakeholder participation in governance, primarily by employees. Without mechanisms to ensure that the people most affected by corporate decisions have some role in shaping them, the promises of dignity, opportunity, and fairness remain precarious.

Collaborate with CorpGov.net on Social Media (or Leave a Reply at the bottom)

Linkedin
BlueSky
Facebook
Mastodon
Substack
X (formerly Twitter)

Governance Structures: Related Posts

Empowering Employees 2021

The Making of a Democratic Economy: Review Essay

BuyThisPlatform: Twitter Explores Co-op Capitalism

What Ought to Be: Why Grow Up?

Corporate Governance: Opening Essay

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments are closed.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes