Attorneys General Seek to Extend Trumpism to the EU cartoon

Attorneys General Seek to Extend Trumpism to the EU

Attorneys General of 16 U.S. States sent a letter (Meta_CSRD_CSDDD) to Mark Zulerberg, encouraging Meta not to comply with European law, which, in practical effect, could amount to a violation of European legal obligations. The letter contains implicit and explicit threats suggesting that if Meta complies with the EU’s CSRD and CSDDD, it may be violating U.S. (or state) laws and could face legal consequences, including enforcement action.

Attorneys General: Main Points

Objection to CSRD and CSDDD

  • The AGs argue that these EU directives unlawfully impose Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) and Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) standards on U.S. companies.
  • They assert that U.S. law—not EU policy—must govern the operations of American companies, even those with operations in Europe.

Legal Claims and Concerns

  • Ambiguity and extraterritoriality: They claim the reporting requirements force U.S. companies to gather information from unrelated third parties, which is vague and overreaching.
  • Litigation risk: They suggest that CSRD/CSDDD compliance could expose companies to Consumer protection suits (e.g., deceptive trade practices); Antitrust enforcement; Claims of unconstitutional race-based discrimination under U.S. law (specifically citing Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard, 600 U.S. 181 (2023)).

Political Framing

  • The AGs frame ESG/DEI as aligned with Biden Administration policies and in conflict with Trump Administration priorities.
  • They reference a 2025 Executive Order that withdrew the U.S. from the Paris Agreement again (Executive Order No. 14162).

Call to Action

  • The AGs urge Meta to refuse to comply with the CSRD and CSDDD.
  • They request a formal response within 30 days detailing how Meta is disavowing EU mandates.

Attorneys General: Possible Grounding

U.S. companies must comply with U.S. federal and state law for activities within U.S. jurisdiction. For example, if ESG/DEI-related disclosures are materially misleading to U.S. consumers or investors, state AGs can investigate or sue under their own consumer protection laws. Collective adoption of ESG or DEI mandates across industries (e.g., coordinated climate commitments) may draw antitrust concerns if they restrain trade or harm competition.

Attorneys General: Overstep

Extraterritorial laws are common and enforceable

  • The EU has jurisdiction over companies doing business within the EU, just as the US has jurisdiction over companies doing business here. Meta’s European subsidiaries must comply with EU laws as a condition of market access.
  • This is not illegal “extraterritorial” enforcement—it’s how cross-border regulation works. U.S. firms operate under foreign law abroad all the time (e.g., GDPR, UK Bribery Act).

EU compliance ≠ U.S. law violation (necessarily)

  • Complying with CSRD/CSDDD does not automatically violate U.S. law. Only if Meta implements those policies domestically in a way that violates U.S. law (e.g., imposing racial quotas) would it create legal risk.
  • There’s no law prohibiting U.S. companies from making sustainability disclosures or evaluating human rights impacts abroad.

The CSRD and CSDDD do not mandate DEI hiring

  • The CSDDD focuses on supply chain due diligence for human rights and environmental harm, not DEI quotas.
  • The AGs conflate DEI and ESG in a way that misrepresents the EU directives’ actual legal requirements.

The Trump Administration does not have legal force beyond the Executive Branch

AGs cite Trump’s Executive Order removing the U.S. from the Paris Agreement (again), but that does not prevent private companies from voluntarily aligning with those goals or complying with foreign laws.

Attorneys General: Bottomline

The letter encourages Meta to prioritize U.S. political and legal norms—even if doing so results in non-compliance with EU law. That amounts to encouraging conduct that could violate European legal obligations. Whether this is explicit encouragement to break the law or political pressure to resist foreign mandates is partly a matter of semantics, but the legal and practical implications are real.

Attorneys General: Targeted Others Too

Similar letters went to at least Microsoft Corporation, Alphabet Inc. (i.e., Google) & Meta Platforms, Inc. All were signed by the AGs from Florida, Alabama, Alaska, Arkansas, Georgia, Idaho, Iowa, Kansas, Louisiana, Mississippi, Montana, Nebraska, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, and Texas.

A letter by business associations (e.g., U.S. Chamber of Commerce) on October 31, 2025, addressed to U.S. trade/administration officials regarding the EU’s CSDDD and CSRD. This is more of a trade/regulatory lobbying letter than a direct letter to individual companies.

Five state attorneys general (Florida, Texas, Iowa, Nebraska, Montana) issued letters to three sustainability/standard‑setting groups (e.g., the Consumer Goods Forum, the GreenBlue Institute, the U.S. Plastics Pact) regarding recycling and circular‑economy collaborations, warning of antitrust and consumer‑protection risks.

Attorneys General: Trumpism Extended

These letters signal that U.S. state‑level enforcement is looking at companies and collaborations engaged in ESG/Sustainability/DEI initiatives or subject to EU mandates (CSRD/CSDDD).

For companies: Even if a company is not explicitly named in the big tech letters, if it has significant EU operations or participates in sustainability/standard‑setting collaborations, it is on notice.

The concerns are: U.S. law conflicts (perceived) with EU mandates; potential liability; antitrust/consumer‑protection risk for sustainability collaborations.

The Attorneys General are using tactics of intimidation taken directly from the Trump playbook toward ESG, DEI, and transnational regulatory frameworks. These tactics align with a growing political and legal movement aimed at discrediting, defunding, or legally undermining ESG and DEI initiatives.

  • Using state power to chill corporate compliance with global ESG/DEI standards;

  • Framing international sustainability law as a threat to U.S. sovereignty;

  • Reframing compliance with global norms as legally risky behavior under U.S. law;

  • Employing legal threats as a deterrent against progressive corporate governance.

These tactics are both ideological and strategic, designed to reverse the post-2016 momentum toward ESG/DEI integration into corporate risk management—especially in multinational firms like Meta.

CorpGov.net’s Conclusion

Since 1995, we have stood for democratizing corporate governance. Democratic forms of governance in both the economic and political spheres result in greater human agency, engagement, and productivity. Tyranny and oligarchy are counterproductive and run counter to a salubrious environment.

The horrible letter from the Attorneys General is less about technical legal conflict and more about forcing companies like Meta to pick political sides: align with Trump-style American nationalism and oligarchy or “foreign globalist mandates,” grounded in more democratic systems.

This echoes Trump’s broad strategy of pressuring companies (Disney, Nike, social media platforms) to abandon progressive policies or face political backlash. My advice: Don’t give in to threats and intimidation.

Here’s a bumper sticker we started selling in about 1979, when I was an NIMH fellow at Boston College studying what governance systems are best for employees, companies, and society. I still have one on my car, 46 years later. Corporations should not be democratic-free zones.

Collaborate with CorpGov.net on Social Media (or Leave a Reply at the bottom)

Linkedin
BlueSky
Facebook
Mastodon
Substack
X (formerly Twitter)

PS – After suing Mark Zuckerberg for breach of fiduciary duty and losing, I didn’t think I would be defending him so soon. Judge Laster ruled that directors have a duty to the firm and to the shares; the shareholders are “incidental.” That stands fiduciary duty on its head.  Still, two wrongs don’t make a right, so I’m standing up for poor Mark in his battle against state Attorneys General.

Attorneys General: Related Posts

Reclaiming Fiduciary Duty

 

Tariffs – Quiet Diplomacy v Kiss My Ass

David Brooks Misreads the Democratic Left

Restore Shareholder Proposal Rights

Trump: Draining the Swamp

Trump Celebrates Labor Day

Trump Jump: Disclose Political Expenses

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments are closed.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes