Archive | Book-Paper Reviews

Reviews of books and significant research papers.

Employee Assembly to Study Partial Employee Ownership at PANW

Employee Assembly to Study Partial Employee Ownership at PANW

I recently listened to Freakonomics Radio: Does Democracy Really Need Elections? In it, Stephen Dubner examines sortition, the ancient Athenian practice of filling public bodies by lottery rather than election. The episode is about government. As someone who has filed shareholder proposals since 2000, I kept hearing a description of corporate governance. It also gave […]

Continue Reading · 0
Financial Statement Analysis

Financial Statement Analysis: Investor Self-Defense with an Activist’s Edge

Les Greenberg’s Financial Statement Analysis: A Self-Defense Manual for Independent Investors is neither a conventional accounting textbook nor a promise of effortless market-beating returns. It is a practitioner’s guide built around a more modest—and more useful—goal: helping ordinary investors avoid preventable mistakes. Greenberg combines basic accounting, behavioral finance, cautionary history, personal experience, and a spreadsheet-based […]

Continue Reading ·
Rebalancing Capitalism Requires Rebalancing Power

Rebalancing Capitalism Requires Rebalancing Power

The recent UK-based EY analysis, How capital allocation can rebalance capitalism in a changing world, offers a timely and largely accurate diagnosis of the system’s current tensions. Capitalism, the authors argue, is not failing; it is delivering precisely what its incentives reward—efficient allocation of capital toward short-term financial returns, scale, and market dominance. This framing […]

Continue Reading ·
Regulation Membership & Shared Capitalism Without Control Capture

Regulation Membership & Shared Capitalism Without Control Capture

What if the biggest mistake in corporate governance is thinking we must choose between capitalism and democracy? That false choice is holding back innovation in ownership itself. New models—from cooperative “Regulation Membership” to employee ownership without control capture—challenge the idea that scale requires concentrated power. They show how ownership can expand without sacrificing markets, liquidity, […]

Continue Reading ·
How Virtual Shareholder Meetings Silence Investors

Muted at the Mic: How Virtual-only Shareholder Meetings Silence Investors

Virtual-only shareholder meetings were sold as a tool for broader access, but new evidence shows they are increasingly used to control dissent, filter investor questions, and weaken accountability. Drawing on Miriam Schwartz-Ziv’s groundbreaking research and years of shareholder experience, this post explains how virtual AGMs silence investor voice—and what reforms are needed to restore transparency […]

Continue Reading ·
Updating Fiduciary Duty to Address Systemic Risk in the United States

Updating Fiduciary Duty to Address Systemic Risk

Updating Fiduciary Duty to Address Systemic Risk. Paul Rissman highlights a growing conflict between corporate directors and diversified investors. This post builds on that insight, proposing practical legal reforms—from redefining materiality to empowering employee and retail shareholders—to align fiduciary duty with systemic risk and modern portfolio theory. The goal is not to abandon shareholder primacy, […]

Continue Reading ·
The Handbook of System-Level Investing

The Handbook of System-Level Investing: From Beta to Ballots

System-level investing is not an ESG add-on—it’s what remains once you recognize that “externalities” are actually the primary drivers of reducing long-term returns. 75–94% of portfolio returns come from market-wide “beta.” Ignoring systemic risks like climate, inequality, and governance breakdowns isn’t sophistication—it’s negligence. The Handbook of System-Level Investing provides shareholder advocates with what we’ve long […]

Continue Reading ·
The Republic of the Company

From Corporate Disenfranchisement to Shared Capitalism

Corporate democracy fails when ownership lacks informed voice. Why do shareholders with extensive legal rights so often have so little real influence? Corporate Disenfranchisement, by Sergio Alberto Gramitto Ricci and Christina Sautter, describes the problem as a “rights–power gap.” Corporate governance gives shareholders formal tools—votes, proposals, litigation rights—but the institutional environment often prevents most investors […]

Continue Reading ·
Bob Monks, his wife Millie and my wife Myra Kalani Young after breakfast in Maine

A Letter to Robert A. G. Monks

Dear Bob, I read your final reflections—Advice to a Younger Me—not once, but several times. Intending to write a book review. I ended up writing this letter of reflection because that’s what your last book invites readers to do. Yours is not really an autobiography. It is a reckoning. And it is impossible to read […]

Continue Reading ·
Rule 14a-8 A Cautionary Tale

Rule 14a-8: A Failed Experiment in Merit Regulation (Still)

Rule 14a-8: A Cautionary Tale About Abandoning Shareholder Voice Alan Palmiter’s recent essay, Rule 14a-8: A Failed Experiment in Merit Regulation (Still), offers a troublesome critique of the SEC’s long-standing role as arbiter of shareholder proposal “merits.” His diagnosis will resonate with many who have spent time in the trenches of Rule 14a-8. We have […]

Continue Reading ·
Shareholders with Voice. That's the part of capitalism an increasing number of boards hate.

Shareholder Primacy

“Shareholder primacy is good for companies, employees, and even for other stakeholders,” Nell Minow recently said in a recent Keynote Address to ICGN. She also referenced an old, but still timely, “New Yorker cartoon with a woman raising her hand at an annual shareholder meeting, and one of the executives whispering to another, ‘This is […]

Continue Reading ·
Governance Structures Matter: Employees Need a Voice at the Table to Raise Productivity and Address Wealth Inequality

Governance Structures Missing in Whittaker’s Vision

In his recent essay, Capitalism at Its Best: America’s Next 250 Years Starts Now, Martin Whittaker, CEO of JUST Capital, offers a thoughtful, historically grounded, and forward-looking call for stakeholder capitalism. He rightly highlights the fraying social contract at the heart of American economic life, identifies the practical aspirations of working people—security, dignity, purpose—and underscores […]

Continue Reading ·
Matteo Gatti, Corporate Power and the Politics of Change

Matteo Gatti, Corporate Power and the Politics of Change

Spoken introduction: Matteo Gatti’s Corporate Power and the Politics of Change  (hardcover, Kindle) is a profoundly original and lucidly argued work that captures one of the defining transformations of our political era: the migration of governance from parliaments to boardrooms. In crisp, interdisciplinary prose that blends corporate law, political economy, and democratic theory, Gatti reveals […]

Continue Reading ·
Values Primacy & Total Governance Through Activism

Values‑Primacy & Total Governance Through Activism

Values-Primacy & Total Governance Through Activism, by Carliss Chatman and Sergio Gramitto Ricci, argues that everyday stakeholder actions—walkouts, boycotts, consumer backlash, viral campaigns, and proxy voting—function as a real, if often unacknowledged, system of corporate governance. When individuals coordinate across their multiple social roles (worker, consumer, investor, community member), they shape corporate identity more durably […]

Continue Reading ·
More Funds, More Choices, Less-Control.

More Funds, More Choices, Less Control

More funds, with many specialized funds created to meet different investor preferences, will likely lead to less monitoring and control by traditional fiduciaries. What implications does that have for those of us interested in shaping corporations, which in turn shape us, to be more democratic and more positive in their contributions to a salubrious environment […]

Continue Reading ·
David Brooks Misreads the Democratic Left

David Brooks Misreads the Democratic Left

David Brooks argues that Donald Trump and the MAGA movement have co-opted the revolutionary playbook of the radical left. His October 2025 column, “Hey, Lefties! Trump Has Stolen Your Game,” is correct that MAGA borrows left-wing rhetorical tools—anti-elitism, distrust of institutions, and even the performance of rebellion. But he misreads what those ideas meant in […]

Continue Reading ·
The Proxy Voting Choice Revolution

The Proxy Voting Choice Revolution: Quick Thoughts

The Proxy Voting Choice Revolution is a paper by Alon Brav, Tao Li, Dorothy S. Lund, and Zikui Pan, dated September 12, 2025. It was published by the European Corporate Governance Institute – Law Working Paper No. 875/2025, HKU Jockey Club Enterprise Sustainability Global Research Institute Paper No. 2025/145, available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=5500098 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.5500098. The paper […]

Continue Reading ·
Corporatocracy

Corporatocracy – Assigned Reading for 2025

Corporatocracy — Ciara Torres-Spelliscy‘s recently published book, Corporatocracy: How to Protect Democracy from Dark Money and Corrupt Politicians, dissects the mechanisms of corporate power and connects them to broader societal issues such as inequality, environmental degradation, and the erosion of democracy. In this work, she provides a roadmap for understanding and resisting Corporatocracy. She offers […]

Continue Reading ·
Portfolios on the Ballot 2024

Portfolios on the Ballot 2024

Portfolios on the Ballot 2024 (POTB 2024), sponsored by The Shareholder Commons (TSC), is designed to guide investors in voting their proxies with a systems-first approach. I fully endorse this initiative. Their report emphasizes the importance of protecting the social and environmental systems that underpin the value of all companies within a diversified investment portfolio. […]

Continue Reading ·
Leading by Example

Leading by Example: Proxy Pre-Disclosures Influence Outcomes

Leading by Example. Norges Bank Investment Management (NBIM) has already gained influence after deciding to pre-disclose its proxy votes its proxy votes (typically 5 days before AGM) beginning in 2021. Following NBIM’s pre-disclosure to vote against a proposal, opposition by other shareholders increases by approximately 2.7%. Compare that to ISS (12%) and Glass Lewis (6.5%). […]

Continue Reading ·
Ownership

Ownership: Rosen & Case

  Ownership: Reinventing companies, Capitalism, and Who Owns What by Corey Rosen and John Case should be read by every director on the board of public pension funds. I (James McRitchie) am planning to send a copy to all the board members of CalPERS once newly elected members take office next year. In celebration of […]

Continue Reading ·
Saving American Democracy in the Age of Citizens United

Saving American Democracy in the Age of Citizens United

Saving American Democracy in the Age of Citizens United, that’s the subtitle of a new book by Robert A.G. Monks entitled The Emperor’s Nightmare. The subtitle speaks to the book’s forward thrust. The title puts that in the context of a long journey in corporate governance by Monks. The cover of Power and Accountability in 1991 […]

Continue Reading ·
Six New Rules of Business With Judy Samuelson

Six New Rules of Business With Judy Samuelson

Six New Rules of Business: Creating Real Value in a Changing World (Berrett-Koehler, 2021) is Judy Samuelson’s latest book. Fresh off her testimony to Congress on shareholder primacy, discuss the issues with Judy on Corporate Accountability Forums, Monday 3/28/2022 at 2 pm Eastern – Register now to participate.  (more…)

Continue Reading ·
21st Century Investing

21st Century Investing

21st Century Investing: Redirecting Financial Strategies to Drive Systems Change is one book we hope investment fund trustees are reading and taking advice from. There are far too many green-washing funds trying to appeal to our green wishes. Money is flowing into ESG funds faster than ever. Many of us recognize that investing and shareholder advocacy […]

Continue Reading ·
2022 The 100 Most Overpaid CEOs

2022 The 100 Most Overpaid CEOs

2022 The 100 Most Overpaid CEOs (release). As You Sow and HIP Investor have done it again. Read it and weep. Then take action. Vote against these pay packages AND the compensation committee members. Also, vote for proposals aimed at disclosure and more equitable distribution of incentive shares. I filed several such proposals listed in […]

Continue Reading ·
Worker Voice and the New Corporate Boardroom: Aspen Institute Business & Society

Worker Voice and the New Corporate Boardroom

Worker Voice and the New Corporate Boardroom is a new paper from the Aspen Institute Business & Society, based on a series of roundtables Idea Lab on Worker Voice in Corporate Governance. Whether the focus is on wages, worker health & safety or diversity, equity & inclusion, the year 2020 opened up new conversations about […]

Continue Reading ·
Corporate Governace Gaming for the Planet

Corporate Governance Gaming

 Corporate Governance Gaming: The Power of Retail Investors is delicious snacking, not just for Robinhood and Reddit GenZ’ers, but also for some Boomers who have tried to democratize corporate governance for decades. How many times have we rolled our eyes reading about GameStop and the frenzy of meme stocks? Crazy? Yes, but also exuding potential, explored […]

Continue Reading ·
Accountable: The Rise of Citizen Capitalism

Accountable: The Rise of Citizen Capitalism

Accountable may be an exception. Not many books on capitalism and corporate governance have the potential to spread like a meme. O’Leary and Valdamanis have a rare talent for using memorable terms like the Two-Buffett Paradox, Fiduciary Absolutism, and Milgram-Nixon Syndrome. Buy it on Amazon and I might get a few cents for the referral. I […]

Continue Reading ·
Moving Beyond Modern Portfolio Theory

Moving Beyond Modern Portfolio Theory: Reflections

Moving Beyond Modern Portfolio Theory: Timeliness In the spirit of Kuhn, this book eviscerates modern portfolio theory, arguing for a more systemic approach centered around human values and intentionality. I had similar nascent thoughts in 1967 when I concluded economics, based on “rational” actor assumptions of homo economicus, was not grounded in science. Lukomnik and Hawley aptly […]

Continue Reading ·
Exit vs Voice

Exit vs Voice

Exit vs Voice? (link) Which strategy is most effective in moving us in a positive direction? Although most investors, especially retail investors, appear focused on exit by moving to ESG funds, the authors conclude voice is the more effective tool. From the abstract: We study the relative effectiveness of exit (divestment and boycott) and voice […]

Continue Reading ·
Giant Shadow of Corporate Gadflies

The Giant Shadow of Corporate Gadflies

The Giant Shadow of Corporate Gadflies, by Yaron Nili and Kobi Kastiel, (download at SSRN) is one of the more objective reviews of the recent influence of “gadflies” on corporate governance in America. It might have been even better if the authors had discussed their work with the subjects of their study – the gadflies. (Disclosure: […]

Continue Reading ·
Conservative TV

Conservative TV and Corporate Social Responsibility

Conservative TV and Corporate Social Responsibility. Again, public opinion is the driver. A 2017 Pew Research Center study found that 37% of Americans get their news from local television news. Only 28% get their news from cable TV, while 26% tune into network news. Sinclair Broadcasting expands by acquiring those trusted local TV stations and […]

Continue Reading ·
BRT's Stakeholder Capitalism

BRT’s Stakeholder Capitalism

BRT’s Stakeholder Capitalism Exposed Lucian Bebchuk and Roberto Tallarita recently published an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal, ‘Stakeholder’ Capitalism Seems Mostly for Show. “If CEOs really intended to amend their companies’ purpose, they’d at least consult their boards first.” In an email with a link to the op-ed and the study upon which it is based, Bebchuk […]

Continue Reading ·

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes